Does VAT exemption for ‘welfare services’ extend to provision of a payroll service? Cheshire Centre for Independent Living case

*Update*: The Upper Tribunal granted HMRC permission to appeal. Cheshire Centre for Independent Living withdrew from the Upper Tribunal appeal. The decision of the First-tier Tribunal has been set aside and HMRC’s appeal allowed.

_________________

Cheshire Centre for Independent Living (‘the charity’) has been involved in a long-running dispute with HMRC over the VAT treatment of charges made to disabled persons in running a payroll service.  The scenario arises as follows.

A disabled person may need a carer.  Where possible, they are encouraged to engage directly with their carer, so they become an employer.  The charity gets involved in a number of ways, one of which is to offer to manage remuneration of the carer.  This means running a payroll service for the one employee.  But this is not a ‘plain vanilla’ payroll, since extra guidance and help is needed to fulfil it, as a consequence of the disability of the customer, and this is duly provided.  It is the charges made for this payroll service that are the focus of this case.  HMRC said the supplies were standard rated, whereas the charity says they are exempt as a welfare supply.

The matter was litigated, and the First tier Tribunal has decided that the service is exempt from VAT.  We hope that HMRC accepts this and does not appeal, but that is a possible next step.

The core of the charity’s case is that one should not seek only to assess the objective content of a service, divorced from the capacities of its recipient, but should consider what the service means to that particular recipient (or class of recipients).  It is the nature of the need that determines if it is welfare.  And the exemption applies solely to charities making supplies to people in certain special classes which denote some from of social security aspect.  The tribunal accepted this.

It also accepted the view that, without the payroll service, the disabled user would not have the capacity to engage the carer.  If charged VAT on the service, the user’s benefits payment would be eroded further by that VAT charge leaving less to use to pay for the carer’s time, thus reducing the level of welfare.  It accepted that the service was only relevant as a result of the need for care services, and was thus of no independent utility for the user.  It was, in the words of the provisions of the Principal VAT Directive, “closely linked” with welfare activity.  It merely better enabled enjoyment of the supply of welfare by the carer, which (HMRC agreed) was, in itself, an exempt welfare service[1] (though if the persons were employed, it seems that the carer did not supply a service that was within the scope of VAT at all).  And the intention behind the welfare exemption was served by exempting this service, as it was part and parcel of the care provision.

Even though the facts of the case showed that this payroll service had features that went beyond the usual processes for payroll per se, to deal with the particular needs of these customers, it appears that the tribunal did not even rely on these differentiators.  It was sufficient that the service was ‘ancillary’ to the welfare supply in the manner discussed above, to give a basis for the exemption.

It is curious that, if HMRC accepted (as they appeared to do) that the carer was providing exempt services to the final consumer, they did not apply the principles from the CJEU decision of Stichting Kinderopvang Enschede C-415/04, which established that the services of arranging an exempt welfare service were exempt when provided by a charitable body.  But, in any case, the tribunal was satisfied, without reliance on that decision, that these services were ‘closely linked’ to welfare work, and that was enough to satisfy the test.

It is difficult to discern the tax policy rationale for HMRC’s intended outcome, since it fails to take account of government policy in seeking to give as much independence to disabled users as possible, and fails to look at the position as a whole.  HMRC needlessly challenged a case where they could sensibly have accepted the more permissive path with no risk of appearing to stretch the exemption to breaking point, nor to open the proverbial floodgates to abuse.

[1] Paragraph 53 of decision

Graham Elliott is Technical Adviser to the Charity Tax Group

Comments

  1. JeromeCoalm says:

    alo 789: alo789 dang nh?p – alo789in

  2. ArthurSaulk says:

    http://interpharmonline.com/# canadian drug
    canadian pharmacy review

  3. Jamesbub says:

    buying from online mexican pharmacy: mexican pharmacy online store – mexican drug stores online

  4. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.com/# india pharmacy without prescription

  5. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://interpharmonline.com/# best canadian online pharmacy
    canadian drug pharmacy

  6. Willisgal says:

    https://interpharmonline.com/# canadian pharmacy 365

  7. GeorgeAdect says:

    canada drugs online: most reliable canadian online pharmacies – safe reliable canadian pharmacy

  8. ArthurSaulk says:

    http://interpharmonline.com/# canadian pharmacy reviews
    www canadianonlinepharmacy

  9. Jamesbub says:

    mexican pharmacy online store: mexican pharmacy online order – mexican pharmacy online order

  10. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.com/# online pharmacy india

  11. GeorgeAdect says:

    lowest prescription prices online india: lowest prescription prices online india – online medicine shopping in india

  12. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.shop/# buying from online mexican pharmacy
    maple leaf pharmacy in canada

  13. Jamesbub says:

    canadian pharmacy meds: legitimate canadian pharmacies online – vipps approved canadian online pharmacy

  14. Willisgal says:

    http://indiamedfast.com/# IndiaMedFast.com

  15. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://interpharmonline.com/# ordering drugs from canada
    canadian world pharmacy

  16. Jamesbub says:

    online pharmacy india: online medicine shopping in india – online medicine shopping in india

  17. Willisgal says:

    http://indiamedfast.com/# IndiaMedFast

  18. HowardNag says:

    canadian pharmacy online ship to usa: highest rated canadian online pharmacy – onlinepharmaciescanada com

  19. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.com/# MexicanPharmInter
    real canadian pharmacy

  20. MonteSmure says:

    IndiaMedFast india online pharmacy store India Med Fast

  21. Jamesbub says:

    pharmacy rx world canada: certified canada pharmacy online – canadian pharmacy ltd

  22. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.com/# india online pharmacy store

  23. HowardNag says:

    best canadian online pharmacy: Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US – reputable canadian pharmacy

  24. ArthurSaulk says:

    http://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican pharmacy online order
    canada ed drugs

  25. Jamesbub says:

    lowest prescription prices online india: IndiaMedFast – buying prescription drugs from india

  26. Willisgal says:

    https://interpharmonline.com/# canadian drug pharmacy

  27. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican drug stores online
    online canadian pharmacy

  28. Terrynom says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra jelly kopen

  29. Williamaxowl says:

    over the counter sildenafil: buy Viagra over the counter – Generic 100mg Easy

  30. GregorypeF says:

    cialis without a doctor prescription: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  31. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra 100mg kopen

  32. Terrynom says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# best price for viagra 100mg

  33. Williamaxowl says:

    kamagra gel kopen: kamagra gel kopen – kamagra jelly kopen

  34. GregorypeF says:

    Officiele Kamagra van Nederland: kamagra gel kopen – KamagraKopen.pro

  35. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  36. Terrynom says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# KamagraKopen.pro

  37. Williamaxowl says:

    kamagra gel kopen: kamagra 100mg kopen – kamagra 100mg kopen

  38. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# cialis without a doctor prescription

  39. GregorypeF says:

    buy generic 100mg viagra online: viagra canada – Generic100mgEasy

  40. Terrynom says:

    http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  41. Kennethsnoda says:

    http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  42. GregorypeF says:

    kamagra kopen nederland: kamagra kopen nederland – kamagra kopen nederland

  43. Williamaxowl says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – Tadalafil Easy Buy

  44. Terrynom says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Buy generic 100mg Viagra online

  45. Williamaxowl says:

    Officiele Kamagra van Nederland: KamagraKopen.pro – KamagraKopen.pro

  46. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra kopen nederland

  47. GregorypeF says:

    Kamagra Kopen Online: KamagraKopen.pro – kamagra gel kopen

  48. Terrynom says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# cialis without a doctor prescription

  49. Williamaxowl says:

    Kamagra Kopen Online: kamagra gel kopen – Kamagra Kopen

  50. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# KamagraKopen.pro

  51. GregorypeF says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  52. Terrynom says:

    http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Tadalafil Easy Buy

  53. Williamaxowl says:

    kamagra kopen nederland: Kamagra Kopen Online – Officiele Kamagra van Nederland

  54. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://generic100mgeasy.com/# buy generic 100mg viagra online

  55. GregorypeF says:

    Tadalafil Easy Buy: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – Tadalafil Easy Buy

  56. Williamaxowl says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – Tadalafil Tablet

  57. Terrynom says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# Tadalafil Easy Buy

  58. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# cialis without a doctor prescription

  59. Williamaxowl says:

    kamagra jelly kopen: KamagraKopen.pro – Officiele Kamagra van Nederland

  60. GregorypeF says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com: Tadalafil Easy Buy – Tadalafil Easy Buy

  61. Terrynom says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# buy generic 100mg viagra online

  62. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen

  63. Williamaxowl says:

    Tadalafil price: Generic Tadalafil 20mg price – cialis without a doctor prescription

  64. GregorypeF says:

    viagra without prescription: Viagra online price – Sildenafil 100mg price

  65. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra jelly kopen

  66. Terrynom says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra 100mg kopen

  67. GregorypeF says:

    KamagraKopen.pro: Officiele Kamagra van Nederland – kamagra pillen kopen

  68. Williamaxowl says:

    kamagra 100mg kopen: kamagra pillen kopen – Kamagra Kopen

  69. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen Online

  70. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап зеркало – пин ап вход

  71. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап казино официальный сайт: https://pinupkz.life/

  72. JamesVal says:

    пинап казино – пинап казино

  73. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап – пин ап казино

  74. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап казино: https://pinupkz.life/

  75. JamesVal says:

    пин ап казино – пин ап казино официальный сайт

  76. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап казино – пин ап казино

  77. JamesVal says:

    пин ап казино – pinup 2025

  78. Jessenuh says:

    pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/

  79. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап – пин ап казино официальный сайт

  80. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап казино зеркало: https://pinupkz.life/

  81. WilliamSaink says:

    пинап казино – пин ап казино

  82. JamesVal says:

    пин ап казино зеркало – пин ап вход

  83. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап: https://pinupkz.life/

  84. JamesVal says:

    pinup 2025 – pinup 2025

  85. Jessenuh says:

    pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/

  86. JamesVal says:

    пинап казино – пинап казино

  87. Jessenuh says:

    pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/

  88. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап зеркало – пин ап казино официальный сайт

  89. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап: https://pinupkz.life/

  90. Michaelsip says:

    Apoteket online: Apotek hemleverans recept – apotek online recept

  91. Derekscory says:

    kamagra: Kamagra Oral Jelly – kamagra

  92. Michaelsip says:

    Online apotheek Nederland met recept: Apotheek Max – Beste online drogist

  93. Derekscory says:

    Apotek hemleverans recept: apotek pa nett – apotek online recept

  94. HomerCob says:

    http://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apotek hemleverans idag

  95. Michaelsip says:

    apotek online: Apoteket online – Apotek hemleverans recept

  96. Louisbeece says:

    https://kamagrapotenzmittel.com/# Kamagra Oral Jelly

  97. Derekscory says:

    apotek online recept: apotek pa nett – Apotek hemleverans recept

  98. HomerCob says:

    http://apotheekmax.com/# Online apotheek Nederland met recept

  99. Michaelsip says:

    Apotek hemleverans idag: Apotek hemleverans idag – apotek online

  100. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apotek hemleverans idag

  101. Derekscory says:

    apotek pa nett: Apotek hemleverans recept – Apotek hemleverans recept

  102. HomerCob says:

    http://apotheekmax.com/# online apotheek

  103. Michaelsip says:

    apotek online recept: Apotek hemleverans recept – Apotek hemleverans recept

  104. Derekscory says:

    Beste online drogist: Beste online drogist – Apotheek online bestellen

  105. HomerCob says:

    https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apotek hemleverans recept

  106. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotekonlinerecept.shop/# apotek online recept

  107. Michaelsip says:

    Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen: Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen – Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen

  108. Derekscory says:

    ApotheekMax: de online drogist kortingscode – Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept

  109. Louisbeece says:

    https://kamagrapotenzmittel.com/# Kamagra Oral Jelly

  110. Michaelsip says:

    Kamagra Oral Jelly: kamagra – Kamagra Original

  111. Louisbeece says:

    http://apotheekmax.com/# online apotheek

  112. Derekscory says:

    Apotek hemleverans recept: Apoteket online – Apotek hemleverans idag

  113. HomerCob says:

    https://apotheekmax.shop/# Online apotheek Nederland met recept

  114. Michaelsip says:

    Apotheek Max: Online apotheek Nederland met recept – ApotheekMax

  115. Derekscory says:

    Apotek hemleverans recept: Apotek hemleverans recept – Apoteket online

  116. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotheekmax.com/# de online drogist kortingscode

  117. HomerCob says:

    https://apotheekmax.com/# Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept

  118. Michaelsip says:

    Kamagra online bestellen: Kamagra Original – Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen

  119. Derekscory says:

    Kamagra Gel: Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept – Kamagra Oral Jelly

  120. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apoteket online

  121. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotekonlinerecept.shop/# Apoteket online

  122. Michaelsip says:

    Kamagra kaufen: kamagra – Kamagra online bestellen

  123. Derekscory says:

    Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen: Kamagra Gel – Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept

  124. Louisbeece says:

    http://apotheekmax.com/# de online drogist kortingscode

  125. HomerCob says:

    http://apotheekmax.com/# Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept

  126. Michaelsip says:

    Kamagra Gel: Kamagra Gel – Kamagra Gel

  127. Derekscory says:

    Online apotheek Nederland met recept: ApotheekMax – Beste online drogist

  128. ChesterRag says:

    buying prescription drugs in mexico: Agb Mexico Pharm – reputable mexican pharmacies online

  129. Matthewham says:

    http://gocanadapharm.com/# canadian online pharmacy

  130. EdwinItese says:

    www india pharm: india pharmacy mail order – www india pharm

  131. Trenttop says:

    Agb Mexico Pharm: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – Agb Mexico Pharm

  132. ChesterRag says:

    indian pharmacy: www india pharm – online pharmacy india

  133. Matthewham says:

    http://agbmexicopharm.com/# Agb Mexico Pharm

  134. EdwinItese says:

    best india pharmacy: www india pharm – india online pharmacy

  135. Trenttop says:

    buying prescription drugs in mexico online: Agb Mexico Pharm – Agb Mexico Pharm

  136. ChesterRag says:

    medicine in mexico pharmacies: medicine in mexico pharmacies – mexican rx online

  137. EdwinItese says:

    buying prescription drugs in mexico: buying from online mexican pharmacy – Agb Mexico Pharm

  138. Matthewham says:

    https://gocanadapharm.com/# canadapharmacyonline

  139. Trenttop says:

    top 10 pharmacies in india: indianpharmacy com – www india pharm

  140. ChesterRag says:

    Agb Mexico Pharm: purple pharmacy mexico price list – mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs

  141. EdwinItese says:

    pharmacy com canada: canadian pharmacy 24h com – canadian pharmacy world

  142. Matthewham says:

    https://gocanadapharm.shop/# my canadian pharmacy rx

  143. Trenttop says:

    Agb Mexico Pharm: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – mexico drug stores pharmacies

  144. ChesterRag says:

    top 10 online pharmacy in india: www india pharm – www india pharm

  145. Matthewham says:

    https://agbmexicopharm.com/# best online pharmacies in mexico

  146. Trenttop says:

    top 10 pharmacies in india: www india pharm – best online pharmacy india

  147. ChesterRag says:

    www india pharm: www india pharm – www india pharm

  148. EdwinItese says:

    Agb Mexico Pharm: Agb Mexico Pharm – Agb Mexico Pharm

  149. Matthewham says:

    http://wwwindiapharm.com/# www india pharm

  150. ChesterRag says:

    mexico drug stores pharmacies: buying prescription drugs in mexico online – Agb Mexico Pharm

  151. Trenttop says:

    canadian pharmacy cheap: canada drugs online review – onlinecanadianpharmacy 24

  152. EdwinItese says:

    Agb Mexico Pharm: Agb Mexico Pharm – Agb Mexico Pharm

  153. ChesterRag says:

    indian pharmacy online: www india pharm – www india pharm

  154. Matthewham says:

    https://gocanadapharm.shop/# canadian pharmacy oxycodone

  155. Trenttop says:

    online pharmacy canada: GoCanadaPharm – legitimate canadian pharmacy online

  156. ChesterRag says:

    best canadian pharmacy: GoCanadaPharm – canadian pharmacy mall

  157. EdwinItese says:

    www india pharm: mail order pharmacy india – top online pharmacy india

  158. Matthewham says:

    http://agbmexicopharm.com/# Agb Mexico Pharm

  159. Trenttop says:

    Agb Mexico Pharm: Agb Mexico Pharm – Agb Mexico Pharm

  160. ChesterRag says:

    www india pharm: top online pharmacy india – www india pharm

  161. EdwinItese says:

    www india pharm: Online medicine order – best online pharmacy india

  162. Matthewham says:

    https://gocanadapharm.shop/# canadian pharmacy cheap

  163. ChesterRag says:

    п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india: www india pharm – www india pharm

  164. Trenttop says:

    Agb Mexico Pharm: Agb Mexico Pharm – mexican drugstore online

  165. EdwinItese says:

    www india pharm: online shopping pharmacy india – india pharmacy mail order

  166. ChesterRag says:

    best canadian online pharmacy: go canada pharm – canadian family pharmacy

  167. Matthewham says:

    http://agbmexicopharm.com/# Agb Mexico Pharm

  168. LanceHyday says:

    Pred Pharm Net: Pred Pharm Net – online order prednisone

  169. DanielJuh says:

    Pred Pharm Net: Pred Pharm Net – where can i buy prednisone

  170. Michaelniz says:

    Clom Fast Pharm: Clom Fast Pharm – where can i buy cheap clomid price

  171. RichardCus says:

    http://predpharmnet.com/# Pred Pharm Net

  172. LanceHyday says:

    buying generic clomid without a prescription: Clom Fast Pharm – Clom Fast Pharm

  173. Michaelniz says:

    Pred Pharm Net: buy prednisone online without a script – prednisone 4 mg daily

  174. DanielJuh says:

    Pred Pharm Net: 50 mg prednisone canada pharmacy – Pred Pharm Net

  175. RichardCus says:

    http://amonlinepharm.com/# can we buy amoxcillin 500mg on ebay without prescription

  176. Michaelniz says:

    generic clomid price: Clom Fast Pharm – cost of clomid online

  177. LanceHyday says:

    where buy generic clomid pill: how to buy cheap clomid without prescription – Clom Fast Pharm

  178. DanielJuh says:

    Pred Pharm Net: Pred Pharm Net – Pred Pharm Net

  179. RichardCus says:

    https://zithpharmonline.com/# zithromax 500

  180. Michaelniz says:

    Pred Pharm Net: canada pharmacy prednisone – prednisone 1 tablet

  181. LanceHyday says:

    generic amoxicillin: AmOnlinePharm – amoxicillin medicine over the counter

  182. DanielJuh says:

    Pred Pharm Net: otc prednisone cream – 400 mg prednisone

  183. RichardCus says:

    http://amonlinepharm.com/# amoxicillin 500 mg

  184. Michaelniz says:

    lisinopril 125 mg: price of zestril – Lisin Express

  185. LanceHyday says:

    zithromax buy: ZithPharmOnline – where to get zithromax over the counter

  186. DanielJuh says:

    prednisone for cheap: Pred Pharm Net – buy prednisone online no script

  187. Michaelniz says:

    ZithPharmOnline: ZithPharmOnline – zithromax buy

  188. RichardCus says:

    http://zithpharmonline.com/# ZithPharmOnline

  189. DanielJuh says:

    Lisin Express: Lisin Express – Lisin Express

  190. LanceHyday says:

    AmOnlinePharm: AmOnlinePharm – buy amoxicillin online cheap

  191. Michaelniz says:

    prednisone cost us: Pred Pharm Net – price of prednisone 5mg

  192. RichardCus says:

    https://predpharmnet.shop/# Pred Pharm Net

  193. Michaelniz says:

    Lisin Express: Lisin Express – Lisin Express

  194. LanceHyday says:

    AmOnlinePharm: azithromycin amoxicillin – AmOnlinePharm

  195. RichardCus says:

    http://zithpharmonline.com/# zithromax tablets for sale

  196. Michaelniz says:

    where can you buy amoxicillin over the counter: AmOnlinePharm – AmOnlinePharm

  197. DanielJuh says:

    Pred Pharm Net: Pred Pharm Net – Pred Pharm Net

  198. LanceHyday says:

    ZithPharmOnline: ZithPharmOnline – buy zithromax 500mg online

  199. Michaelniz says:

    can you buy zithromax over the counter in australia: how to get zithromax – buy zithromax

  200. RichardCus says:

    https://lisinexpress.shop/# Lisin Express

  201. DanielJuh says:

    amoxicillin 500mg without prescription: purchase amoxicillin online without prescription – AmOnlinePharm

  202. Michaelniz says:

    prednisone for sale without a prescription: Pred Pharm Net – 80 mg prednisone daily

  203. LanceHyday says:

    can you get cheap clomid online: where can i buy generic clomid now – how to buy generic clomid no prescription

  204. RichardCus says:

    https://lisinexpress.com/# prinivil 20mg tabs

  205. DanielJuh says:

    AmOnlinePharm: AmOnlinePharm – amoxicillin without a doctors prescription

  206. Michaelniz says:

    Pred Pharm Net: Pred Pharm Net – Pred Pharm Net

  207. LanceHyday says:

    Lisin Express: Lisin Express – Lisin Express

  208. RichardCus says:

    http://zithpharmonline.com/# zithromax 500mg price

  209. Michaelniz says:

    Lisin Express: medication lisinopril 10 mg – Lisin Express

  210. Bradyket says:

    casino turkey: casibom guncel giris – tГјm casino siteleri casibom1st.com

  211. Weldoniroxy says:

    oyun siteleri: casibom giris – spor siteleri listesi casibom1st.com

  212. Robertjoits says:

    sweet bonanza 1st: sweet bonanza 1st – sweet bonanza giris sweetbonanza1st.shop

  213. DavidJah says:

    https://sweetbonanza1st.shop/# sweet bonanza siteleri

  214. Bradyket says:

    online kumar siteleri: casibom mobil giris – yurt dД±ЕџД± bahis sitesi casibom1st.com

  215. Robertjoits says:

    sweet bonanza yorumlar: sweet bonanza demo – sweet bonanza siteleri sweetbonanza1st.shop

  216. Weldoniroxy says:

    sweet bonanza oyna: sweet bonanza giris – sweet bonanza slot sweetbonanza1st.shop

  217. Bradyket says:

    sweet bonanza siteleri: sweet bonanza – sweet bonanza slot sweetbonanza1st.shop

  218. Robertjoits says:

    casino siteleri 2025: casino siteleri 2025 – casino siteleri 2025 casinositeleri1st.com

  219. Weldoniroxy says:

    casino siteleri 2025: slot casino siteleri – vaycasino casinositeleri1st.com

  220. Bradyket says:

    sweet bonanza slot: sweet bonanza – sweet bonanza oyna sweetbonanza1st.shop

  221. Robertjoits says:

    sweet bonanza slot: sweet bonanza slot – sweet bonanza 1st sweetbonanza1st.shop

  222. Weldoniroxy says:

    bonus veren site: casibom 1st – 100 tl bonus veren bahis siteleri casibom1st.com

  223. Bradyket says:

    casino oyna: casibom – gГјvenilir oyun alma siteleri casibom1st.com

  224. Robertjoits says:

    sweet bonanza: sweet bonanza – sweet bonanza slot sweetbonanza1st.shop

  225. Weldoniroxy says:

    deneme bonusu veren slot siteleri 2025: casibom resmi – en Г§ok freespin veren slot 2025 casibom1st.com

  226. Bradyket says:

    100tl hosgeldin bonusu veren siteler: casibom 1st – en Г§ok kazandД±ran bahis siteleri casibom1st.com

  227. Robertjoits says:

    sweet bonanza 1st: sweet bonanza giris – sweet bonanza oyna sweetbonanza1st.shop

  228. Weldoniroxy says:

    deneme bonusu veren bet siteleri: slot casino siteleri – slot casino siteleri casinositeleri1st.com

  229. Bradyket says:

    casino siteleri 2025: slot casino siteleri – guvenilir casino siteleri casinositeleri1st.com

  230. Robertjoits says:

    sweet bonanza 1st: sweet bonanza demo – sweet bonanza slot sweetbonanza1st.shop

  231. Robertjoits says:

    sweet bonanza giris: sweet bonanza yorumlar – sweet bonanza slot sweetbonanza1st.shop

  232. Bradyket says:

    sweet bonanza oyna: sweet bonanza yorumlar – sweet bonanza giris sweetbonanza1st.shop

  233. Weldoniroxy says:

    sweet bonanza giris: sweet bonanza yorumlar – sweet bonanza demo sweetbonanza1st.shop

  234. Robertjoits says:

    canlД± casino oyna: casibom guncel giris – gГјvenilir oyun alma siteleri casibom1st.com

  235. Bradyket says:

    canlД± casino deneme bonusu veren siteler: casibom giris – betboo plus casibom1st.com

  236. Weldoniroxy says:

    slot casino siteleri: casino siteleri – vidobet giriЕџ casinositeleri1st.com

  237. Robertjoits says:

    casino siteleri: slot casino siteleri – guvenilir casino siteleri casinositeleri1st.com

  238. DavidJah says:

    https://casibom1st.com/# gercek para kazandД±ran casino oyunlarД±

  239. Bradyket says:

    en gГјvenilir bahis: casibom mobil giris – online kumar siteleri casibom1st.com

  240. Weldoniroxy says:

    sweet bonanza demo: sweet bonanza oyna – sweet bonanza demo sweetbonanza1st.shop

  241. Robertjoits says:

    deneme bonusu veren siteler: casino siteleri – guvenilir casino siteleri casinositeleri1st.com

  242. Bradyket says:

    2025 yatД±rД±m ЕџartsД±z deneme bonusu veren siteler: casibom resmi – deneme bonusu bahis siteleri casibom1st.com

  243. Robertjoits says:

    slot casino siteleri: slot casino siteleri – en iyi yabancД± bahis siteleri casinositeleri1st.com

  244. DavidJah says:

    http://casibom1st.com/# kaçak bahis siteleri bonus veren

  245. Bradyket says:

    katД±lД±m bonusu veren bahis siteleri: casibom – como bakery yorumlarД± casibom1st.com

  246. Cletuskar says:

    mexican pharmacy: medication from mexico pharmacy – UsMex Pharm

  247. Dennisviava says:

    Us Mex Pharm: USMexPharm – buying prescription drugs in mexico online

  248. SteveNeoft says:

    https://usmexpharm.com/# Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  249. MicahPneup says:

    Us Mex Pharm: mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmacy

  250. Cletuskar says:

    certified Mexican pharmacy: UsMex Pharm – UsMex Pharm

  251. Dennisviava says:

    Us Mex Pharm: mexican mail order pharmacies – certified Mexican pharmacy

  252. SteveNeoft says:

    https://usmexpharm.shop/# Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  253. Cletuskar says:

    Us Mex Pharm: usa mexico pharmacy – certified Mexican pharmacy

  254. MicahPneup says:

    Us Mex Pharm: usa mexico pharmacy – usa mexico pharmacy

  255. Dennisviava says:

    certified Mexican pharmacy: Us Mex Pharm – USMexPharm

  256. Cletuskar says:

    Mexican pharmacy ship to USA: UsMex Pharm – Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  257. MicahPneup says:

    mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa: Mexican pharmacy ship to USA – UsMex Pharm

  258. Dennisviava says:

    Mexican pharmacy ship to USA: mexican pharmacy – USMexPharm

  259. Cletuskar says:

    mexican pharmacy: mexican pharmacy – mexican pharmacy

  260. SteveNeoft says:

    https://usmexpharm.shop/# mexican pharmacy

  261. MicahPneup says:

    Mexican pharmacy ship to USA: UsMex Pharm – mexican pharmacy

  262. Dennisviava says:

    USMexPharm: usa mexico pharmacy – Us Mex Pharm

  263. Cletuskar says:

    UsMex Pharm: Us Mex Pharm – mexican drugstore online

  264. SteveNeoft says:

    http://usmexpharm.com/# usa mexico pharmacy

  265. MicahPneup says:

    Us Mex Pharm: Us Mex Pharm – Us Mex Pharm

  266. Cletuskar says:

    usa mexico pharmacy: usa mexico pharmacy – USMexPharm

  267. Dennisviava says:

    UsMex Pharm: UsMex Pharm – USMexPharm

  268. Cletuskar says:

    usa mexico pharmacy: USMexPharm – USMexPharm

  269. SteveNeoft says:

    https://usmexpharm.shop/# mexico pharmacies prescription drugs

  270. MicahPneup says:

    certified Mexican pharmacy: UsMex Pharm – Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  271. Cletuskar says:

    Mexican pharmacy ship to USA: mexican pharmacy – Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  272. Dennisviava says:

    certified Mexican pharmacy: Us Mex Pharm – certified Mexican pharmacy

  273. MicahPneup says:

    buying from online mexican pharmacy: USMexPharm – UsMex Pharm

  274. SteveNeoft says:

    https://usmexpharm.shop/# Mexican pharmacy ship to USA

  275. Cletuskar says:

    Mexican pharmacy ship to USA: mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa – mexican pharmacy

  276. WaltonRem says:

    reputable indian pharmacies: п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india – UsaIndiaPharm

  277. Georgestike says:

    online shopping pharmacy india: UsaIndiaPharm – UsaIndiaPharm

  278. CarltonGek says:

    http://usaindiapharm.com/# USA India Pharm

  279. FrankAcino says:

    USA India Pharm: world pharmacy india – best online pharmacy india

  280. WaltonRem says:

    indian pharmacy paypal: indianpharmacy com – USA India Pharm

  281. Georgestike says:

    pharmacy website india: top online pharmacy india – Online medicine order

  282. CarltonGek says:

    https://usaindiapharm.com/# indian pharmacy paypal

  283. FrankAcino says:

    UsaIndiaPharm: buy medicines online in india – Online medicine home delivery

  284. Davidjinge says:

    indian pharmacy online USA India Pharm USA India Pharm

  285. WaltonRem says:

    UsaIndiaPharm: UsaIndiaPharm – USA India Pharm

  286. FrankAcino says:

    Online medicine order: UsaIndiaPharm – UsaIndiaPharm

  287. CarltonGek says:

    https://usaindiapharm.shop/# UsaIndiaPharm

  288. Georgestike says:

    USA India Pharm: USA India Pharm – USA India Pharm

  289. WaltonRem says:

    UsaIndiaPharm: top 10 pharmacies in india – mail order pharmacy india

  290. FrankAcino says:

    india pharmacy: UsaIndiaPharm – top 10 online pharmacy in india

  291. CarltonGek says:

    http://usaindiapharm.com/# USA India Pharm

  292. Georgestike says:

    indian pharmacy online: UsaIndiaPharm – USA India Pharm

  293. FrankAcino says:

    UsaIndiaPharm: online shopping pharmacy india – online shopping pharmacy india

  294. WaltonRem says:

    UsaIndiaPharm: USA India Pharm – reputable indian pharmacies

  295. CarltonGek says:

    https://usaindiapharm.com/# Online medicine home delivery

  296. Georgestike says:

    pharmacy website india: top 10 pharmacies in india – best online pharmacy india

  297. FrankAcino says:

    USA India Pharm: indian pharmacy paypal – UsaIndiaPharm

  298. WaltonRem says:

    mail order pharmacy india: india pharmacy mail order – indian pharmacy paypal

  299. CarltonGek says:

    http://usaindiapharm.com/# USA India Pharm

  300. FrankAcino says:

    online pharmacy india: indian pharmacy – UsaIndiaPharm

  301. FrankAcino says:

    USA India Pharm: UsaIndiaPharm – UsaIndiaPharm

  302. CarltonGek says:

    https://usaindiapharm.shop/# UsaIndiaPharm

  303. Georgestike says:

    UsaIndiaPharm: USA India Pharm – indian pharmacy paypal

  304. WaltonRem says:

    UsaIndiaPharm: UsaIndiaPharm – п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india

  305. FrankAcino says:

    USA India Pharm: UsaIndiaPharm – indian pharmacy online

  306. Davidjinge says:

    indianpharmacy com UsaIndiaPharm india online pharmacy

  307. Georgestike says:

    UsaIndiaPharm: indian pharmacies safe – USA India Pharm

  308. WaltonRem says:

    USA India Pharm: buy medicines online in india – USA India Pharm

  309. FrankAcino says:

    п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india: UsaIndiaPharm – online pharmacy india

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *