Professional negligence and failed tax avoidance schemes

Sonia Ferreira is an Associate in the Commercial Dispute Resolution team at Dentons. Her original article can also be read here.

The High Court of Justice (in the case of Halsall and others v. Champion Consulting Ltd and others [2017] EWHC) has handed down judgment in a professional negligence claim arising out of failed tax avoidance schemes. HHJ Moulder found the tax adviser defendants to be negligent, but nevertheless ruled that, on the facts of the case, the claims were time barred. This article summarises the professional negligence findings and concentrates on the limitation arguments.

Facts

Four partners in a solicitors’ firm (the Claimants) issued proceedings against accountancy firms (individually the Defendant or collectively the Defendants) claiming that the Defendants induced them to invest in two tax schemes: the “charity shell” scheme in 2003 (the Charity Scheme) and the “Scion” film scheme in 2007 (the Film Scheme).

The Claimants asserted that the Defendant introduced them to the Charity Scheme in July 2003 and in October/November 2003 the Defendant’s representative had assured the Claimants that the Charity Scheme would “work effectively”. The Claimants also alleged that the Defendants failed to advise of the significant risk that Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs (HMRC) would challenge the Charity Scheme.

In relation to the Film Scheme, the Claimants argued that the Defendant had not only advised that the prospects of successfully avoiding tax were 75/80% but had failed to advise on the Claimants’ potential liability in a worst-case scenario.

HMRC successfully challenged the schemes and the Claimants did not obtain tax relief. The Claimants issued a claim in negligence on 6 March 2015.

Professional Negligence

The test to determine professional negligence is whether the advisers had acted in a way that no reasonably competent tax adviser could have acted. In SAAMCO v. York Montague Ltd [1997] AC 191, the House of Lords distinguished between two categories which professionals may fall into. First, “the information” category – here the professional merely contributes a limited part of material to the transaction and the client assesses its overall financial and commercial merits. Second, “the advice” category – here the professional considers all of the matters which the client should take into account when assessing whether to enter a transaction and assists the client in the decision-making process. In the latter, the adviser is liable for “all the foreseeable loss which is a consequence of that course of action having been taken” (SAAMCO) even if only one aspect of the advice is negligent.

In relation to the Charity Scheme, the Judge held that, on the facts, the Defendants were clearly acting as advisers and “guiding the whole decision-making process” and so fell into the “advice” category and were liable for all foreseeable loss.  She decided that the Defendant was negligent as no reasonably competent tax adviser could have given unconditional assurances, including that the scheme would “work effectively”.

In relation to the Film Scheme, HHJ Moulder also found that the Defendants advised the Claimants on the course of action to take. Advising that the Film Scheme had a 75% prospect of success was advice which “no reasonably well-informed and competent member of that profession could have given”.

HHJ Moulder held that, in light of the other financial alternatives available, the Claimants would not have entered either scheme but for the Defendants’ negligent advice. Therefore the Defendants’ negligence caused the Claimants’ losses.

The Limitation Act 1980 (LA) – Primary Limitation Period

By way of a reminder, the primary limitation dates for breach of contract and tort claims are:

  • for a breach of contract, the primary limitation is six years from the breach of contract; and
  • for a claim in negligence, the primary limitation is six years from when the cause of action accrues.

This claim was brought for negligence (rather than breach of contract) where the primary limitation period is set out in section 2 of the LA 1980 and which provides that a claim must be issued within six years of the date on which “the cause of action accrued” and the cause of action accrues when damage occurs. Here it began when the party was contractually bound to enter into the transaction. Once the party entered a transaction it was “tied into a commercially disadvantageous straightjacket” (Pegasus Management Holdings SCA v. Ernst & Young [2010] EWCA Civ 181).   Given that the Claimants were contractually bound to enter into the Charity Scheme in 2003 and the Film Scheme in 2007, the primary limitation of six years for bringing a claim had expired for both schemes.

The LA 1980 – Secondary Limitation

For tort claims there is also a secondary limitation date set out in section 14A of the LA 1980 which extends the primary limitation period for three years subject to a longstop date of 15 years.  Pursuant to section 14A(4)(b) a claim will not be considered time barred if it is issued within three years from when the claimant first had “both the knowledge required for bringing an action for damages in respect of the relevant damages … and a right to bring such an action” [emphasis added] (section 14A(5)). There are two tests which determine whether the claimant had the relevant knowledge. These are the “degree of certainty” test and the “degree of detail” test. The degree of certainty test entails “knowing with sufficient confidence to justify embarking on the preliminaries to the issue of the claim form…the claimant must know enough for it to be reasonable to begin to investigate further” (Haward v. Fawcetts [2006] UKHL 9). The degree of detail test is knowing there was a real possibility that the damage was caused by the alleged defendants’ negligence. The Claimants had the burden of proving that they only had the requisite knowledge for the purposes of section 14A after 5 March 2012, being three years before proceedings had been issued.

The Charity Scheme

The Judge dealt with the knowledge of each Claimant separately, except for Mr McDermott who had passed away.

While Mr Halsall had been aware of negotiations between the Defendant and HMRC in December 2009 and had told the Defendant to notify its professional indemnity insurers of a potential claim, he contended that he did not have the requisite knowledge at that point. HHJ Moulder stated that the test for requisite knowledge is whether Mr Halsall knew enough in December 2009 to justify investigating the possibility that the advice was negligent. The Judge held that an inference could be drawn that Mr Halsall had sufficient knowledge in December 2009 “that a reasonable person would consider it sufficiently serious to investigate the possibility that the advice was flawed”. HHJ Moulder also added, in the alternative, that it was beyond doubt that Mr Halsall had the requisite knowledge on 21 June 2011 when he threatened proceedings against the Defendants and requested a meeting with the them to discuss what the Claimants owed “if the schemes were not accepted” and so his claim was clearly out of time since he had this knowledge prior to 5 March 2012.

HHJ Moulder held that Mr Stanton had the requisite knowledge on 27 January 2011, when HMRC notified him that the Charity Scheme was under investigation and so again was out of time.

Finally, in relation to Mr Higgins, HHJ Moulder referred to his email exchanges with the Defendant in late 2009 which contained statements such as “when things go wrong”. The Judge decided that Mr Higgins was aware of HMRC’s investigation and it was therefore reasonable for him to have started investigating then. HHJ Moulder added, in the alternative, that Mr Higgins had the requisite knowledge in June/July 2011 when the Claimants proposed to meet the Defendants, as above. Alternatively, he had the requisite knowledge in February 2012, the date the Claimants received schedules detailing their potential tax liabilities if the scheme failed. Accordingly all these dates were prior to 5 March 2012.

The Film Scheme

The Judge held that Mr Higgins had the requisite knowledge in January 2011, and Mr Stanton and Mr Halsall in late 2011, when HMRC notified each Claimant of its enquiries into tax relief sought for the Film Scheme.

In light of the above, HHJ Moulder decided that the Claimants had the requisite knowledge for the purpose of section 14A of the LA 1980 in relation to both schemes before March 2012. Therefore, despite having held the Defendants liable in negligence, the claims were statute barred.

Commentary

The judgment is a helpful analysis of the circumstances under which advisers will be found liable for negligent advice on tax avoidance schemes and the application of the LA 1980. It provides a salutary lesson that parties who have a potential claim should consider at an early stage when the relevant limitation period starts.

As the dates for calculating when the limitation period commences are different for a breach of contract and a tortious claim, it can sometimes be difficult to determine the correct date and therefore parties with potential claims should seek to identify the relevant dates for each claim as soon as possible, erring on the side of caution if there is any doubt. Further, if the primary limitation periods have passed, there may be longer, secondary limitation periods, but these depend on the facts of each case and careful scrutiny must be given to ascertaining the claimant’s state of knowledge.

If the limitation date is near, parties should consider entering into a standstill agreement to stop time from running. This will give the claimant the opportunity to discuss and seek to settle any dispute with the confidence that they are not prejudicing any potential claim due to a limitation argument.

Comments

  1. Candida says:

    Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization?
    I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but
    I’m not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share.
    Kudos! I saw similar art here: Eco blankets

  2. how to turn off baseboard heater with knob says:

    So, even if you ate a hamburger for dinner final night and skimped on the fruits and veggies, your meal still might need had the assistance of a few bees.

  3. sugar defender ingredients says:

    sugar defender ingredients Uncovering Sugar Defender has been a game-changer
    for me, as I’ve constantly been vigilant about
    managing my blood sugar level degrees. With this supplement,
    I really feel encouraged to organize my wellness, and my latest clinical check-ups have mirrored a substantial turnaround.
    Having a trustworthy ally in my edge gives me with a complacency and confidence,
    and I’m deeply glad for the extensive distinction Sugar Protector has made in my health.

  4. pandora jewelry says:

    The next time I read a blog, Hopefully it does not disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, Yes, it was my choice to read, nonetheless I genuinely believed you’d have something useful to talk about. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you can fix if you were not too busy seeking attention.

  5. 파라존카지노 says:

    This website was… how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally I’ve found something that helped me. Cheers.

  6. 라카지노 says:

    I truly love your blog.. Great colors & theme. Did you develop this web site yourself? Please reply back as I’m looking to create my very own blog and would love to find out where you got this from or just what the theme is named. Many thanks!

  7. which stock is trending today says:

    There’s certainly a lot to know about this issue. I love all of the points you made.

  8. Fintech Revolution: How Businesses can Benefit from Embedded Finance says:

    May I simply just say what a comfort to find an individual who actually understands what they are discussing online. You actually know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. A lot more people should read this and understand this side of your story. It’s surprising you are not more popular because you surely possess the gift.

  9. sugar defender ingredients says:

    sugar defender ingredients
    For years, I’ve battled unpredictable blood glucose swings
    that left me feeling drained and tired. However given that integrating
    Sugar my power degrees are currently stable and regular, and
    I no longer hit a wall in the afternoons. I appreciate that it’s a gentle, all-natural strategy that does not come with any kind of unpleasant negative effects.
    It’s really changed my every day life.

  10. 6m scaffold tower says:

    I confirm. And I have faced it. Let’s discuss this question.

  11. snaptik says:

    Spot on with this write-up, I absolutely think this website needs a great deal more attention. I’ll probably be back again to read more, thanks for the information.

  12. software for mass backlinking says:

    After exploring a number of the blog posts on your web page, I honestly like your way of blogging. I added it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Take a look at my web site as well and let me know how you feel.

  13. ひまわり眼科 受付時間 says:

    In recent years, Chattanooga has appeared in more productions of blockbuster movies and Television shows, in addition to independent films and documentaries.

  14. iq 低い人 顔 says:

    Local governments may, in this way, bring equity by being able to customize public services and even distribution of resources to those groups, effectively dealing with the systemic inequalities.

  15. 卯月読み方 says:

    Brandon. Tonga is a Polynesian nation made up of 170 South Pacific islands, 36 of that are inhabited.

  16. 世界一 資産 国 says:

    As of now, it is the most important marketplace that offers a web based selling of wholesale digital products.

  17. 悪事千里を走る 反対語 says:

    This form calculates your overall capital profits and losses from all of your assets, including cryptocurrency.

  18. サウジアラビア お金 says:

    I’ve enlarged the labels only in that particular row to further help you.

  19. 寒気嘔吐 says:

    Morlai Koroma, Foreman Mechanic, Chrome Mines, Sierra Leone.

  20. 輪島市 掲示板 says:

    Retrieved November 4, 2022.

  21. 石倉 三郎 武勇 伝 says:

    If personal fulfillment is the primary concern and finances are not an issue, a retired physician can find plenty of opportunities to become a community volunteer.

  22. 故事成語蛇足の意味 says:

    Prime engine this season was a 385-horsepower 427-cubic-inch V-8.

  23. ショッピング モール says:

    The GLBA requires companies to give consumers privacy notices that explain the institutions’ information-sharing practices and to protect information collected about individuals.

  24. 蛞蝓 とは says:

    Even nonsmoking dad and mom can act in ways in which inadvertently make it easier for his or her children to begin smoking.

  25. ファーストリテイリングの配当利率は says:

    Thus, other than one of the best charges of curiosity, it’s essential just remember to read and understand all the pieces said within the financial savings papers and application kinds supplied by the bank.

  26. 中村警察署 落とし物 says:

    It suggests that your journey towards success and fulfillment involves continuous growth and expansion.

  27. お控えとして保管 says:

    You see it taking pictures via the roof when there are geo-political tensions.

  28. nisa 債券 利回り says:

    AKA you’ll share the experiences, make memories and maybe even begin lifelong friendships.

  29. ドコモ 保険 300 円 says:

    And sure, this can involve tasting the outcomes of your work.

  30. true関数 使い方 says:

    However, states continue to have the authority to investigate and prosecute fraud involving mutual funds.

  31. 抜書き says:

    Common futures strategy is through hedging.

  32. 経済学 生活 役立つ says:

    The tornado then weakened again and continued to the northeast, inflicting EF1 tree damage in rural areas of Weakley County.

  33. ビジネス ソフト 無料 says:

    The share and securities are traded at a really high quantity so that the investor can turn their inventory into cash whenever required.

  34. 足の指 冷たい says:

    Find out the fee from internet builders.

  35. 大垣共立銀行の株価と配当金は says:

    Individuals, investors and companies invest in the shares in expectation of benefits as the value of the shares increases.

  36. 天気 台風 警報 says:

    How will fallout affect sheltered livestock?

  37. しんきんjリートオープン(毎月決算型) 見通し says:

    By putting extra of the load towards the entrance of the trailer, you may improve the trailer’s means to handle the road.

  38. 地域クーポン 期限 沖縄 says:

    — Parenthetically it may be famous that computer chess was originally launched with the desire to review the technique of human choice making.

  39. フランス化粧品 says:

    A particular trailer for the series was produced by Red Bee Media.

  40. 豚ひき肉炒め says:

    Within the 5th century Ad with the Roman departure from Britain, there have been also appreciable modifications in the usage of glass.

  41. 通路に物を置く人 says:

    Try to imagine your self because the product liability underwriter for your company.

  42. ディズニー 財布 しまむら says:

    What was the biggest fear surrounding Y2K?

  43. 葉が出る 英語 says:

    Callum has been assigned the no.23 squad quantity beforehand assigned to Josh.

  44. 環境 を作る 類語 says:

    By early April, his energy was spent, and he returned to Giverny having painted 30 works over the course of his two campaigns.

  45. 受験者数 英語で says:

    Molecular analysis suggests that the Orinoco dolphins are derived from the Amazon population and will not be genetically distinct.

  46. 〇〇でな方言 says:

    Based on knowledge published by The Wall Avenue Journal Online and the Financial institution of Canada.

  47. 現れる 類語 says:

    The same formula can be applied to corporate and workplaces through effective corporate events.

  48. 面接日程確定メール 例文 says:

    Nevertheless, unlike in the Victorian era, at present’s eclectic model isn’t about acquisition and clutter.

  49. ベンダー資格ランキング says:

    If you want special knowledge to make money on the stock market, then you will also want to consider the wizard training course.

  50. マスク ストラップ 作り方 says:

    The lustre of turquoise is usually waxy to sub vitreous.

  51. ウェルネオシュガーの株価と配当は says:

    One in all the key advantages of investing in hedge funds is their flexibility.

  52. リトアニアとポーランドの間 says:

    This yr also marked the primary use of the term “Scaracters”, in addition to the first official “Ghoul Faculty” for actors participating in the event.

  53. 中森明菜 ライブ nhk says:

    Leverage Risk Management: How to Control It?

  54. 口から生まれた口太郎 says:

    Ralph, Alex (September 2, 2016).

  55. 住友 生命 生命 保険 says:

    What about disease-ridden bushes that are not solely an eyesore but also a liability when the weather turns tough?

  56. f & lc 株価 says:

    You could also be on a wine country adventure, however you’re still riding a bike.

  57. 栄枯盛衰のことわり says:

    Greatest Legal professionals in America recognizes Hickey Legislation Agency in an unprecedented three areas of private Harm-Plaintiffs, Admiralty & Maritime, and Medical Malpractice-Plaintiffs.

  58. 有村かすみあね says:

    With so many companies locked in an intense competition with their business rivals, you have to think out of the box to make your brand stand out from the others.

  59. カタール 語 says:

    Will I play the identical move once more?

  60. 楽天プラチナバンドいつ says:

    Members pay rent for his or her workplace space, which provides most of Innovation Depot’s income.

  61. 都立大学 切りつけ says:

    You need the assist of the bail bonds company, the place your quantity decided by the courtroom shall be paid by the corporate, for the time being.

  62. glcクーペ ダサい says:

    Linear tendencies fit a line to scattered data.

  63. ヤマハ発動機 ドローン says:

    On the subject of home insurance coverage, most people suppose about the same fundamental policies that cowl widespread houses – but what if you live in a unique sort of house?

  64. 名前 画数 11画 女の子 says:

    They possess an expertise in analyzing the investment plan and portfolio administration.

  65. 真岡ぴよぴよ広場 says:

    For a faucet fixture that will stand the test of time, look for models with a PVD finish (physical vapor deposition).

  66. まつのゆうき東谷 says:

    It’d even be integrated with a GPS and a turn-by-flip course system of some form.

  67. レゴランド 年パス 誕生月 says:

    This aquamarine ring is a perfect alternative for individuals who appreciate refined beauty and graceful fashion.

  68. 所狭し 読み方 says:

    Debt relief choices can sometimes be limited to where you live.

  69. 爪の中に虫 夢 says:

    De Gaulle believed that he could persuade the Vichy French forces in Dakar to affix the Allies.

  70. 一兆円 できること says:

    MQ-9 Reaper: Additionally recognized because the Predator B, the Reaper is a larger and more succesful successor to the MQ-1 Predator.

  71. ハサミ種類一覧 says:

    Financial advisor education and training programs services are for financial executive or registered representative that can experience providing service for the busying and selling for the shares and appropriately settling up the investment desired by the client.

  72. フロム・ソフトウェア 株価 says:

    Cleanup Initiatives – so as to maintain the community clear and beautiful, tour operators take part in cleanup initiatives and actions throughout the native communities, employing assistance from their staffs and managing the procedure of proper waste administration.

  73. 投資 入門 セミナー says:

    Smooth, civilized, capable, and fully equipped, it was a truly modern sports car, worthy of comparison with Jaguar’s E-Type yet much cheaper.

  74. driving schools mallow says:

    To ensure you’re fit and well enough to provide services,
    you must complete a medical assessment.

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *