VAT recovery for holding companies – MVM case and HMRC guidance

Dermot Rafferty, Senior Manager at EY, reviews the recent case MVM (C-28/16), a Hungarian referral to to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), which was determined by Order of the Court.

The CJEU has a procedure whereby, if it believes that the answer to a referral is sufficiently clear (e.g. the answer may be clearly deduced from existing case-law), it can determine the case by the issue of an Order, without the need for a full Court hearing or a written Advocate General’s Opinion.  The procedure has been used by the CJEU in relation to this Hungarian referral concerning the entitlement of a holding company, that is actively involved in the management of its subsidiaries (within an energy group), to deduct input tax.  Specifically, the referral addresses a situation where the holding company actively carries on a taxable business in its own right, but does not make a charge for the management of its subsidiaries.

The CJEU has disposed of this referral by the issue of an Order dated 12 January 2017, to the effect that whilst Directive 2006/112/EC provides a wide scope to VAT, only activities of an economic nature are covered by the tax.  In that regard it has previously been held by the Court that an activity is generally considered to be ‘economic’ where it is permanent and is carried out in return for remuneration which is received by the person carrying out the activity.  In order for VAT to be deductible, the input transactions must have a direct and immediate link with the output transactions giving rise to a right of deduction. Thus, the right to deduct VAT charged presupposes that the expenditure is a component of the cost of the output transactions that gave rise to the right to deduct.

The CJEU held that as regards the right of a holding company to deduct VAT on its costs, the Court has previously held that a holding company which does not involve itself directly or indirectly in the management of those undertakings, is not involved in an economic activity and consequently does not have either the status of taxable person or the right to deduct VAT.  However, the position will be otherwise where the holding company is directly or indirectly involved in the management of its subsidiaries.  It follows from settled case-law that the involvement of a holding company in the management of companies in which it has acquired a shareholding constitutes an economic activity within the meaning of Article 9(1) of Directive 2006/112/EC where it entails carrying out transactions which are subject to VAT by virtue of Article 2 of that directive, such as the supply by a holding company to its subsidiaries of administrative, financial, commercial and technical services.

The involvement of a holding company in the management of its subsidiaries, without carrying out transactions subject to VAT under Article 2 of Directive 2006/112/EC, cannot be regarded as an ‘economic activity’.

The CJEU concluded that in the present case, it is apparent that MVM received no remuneration from its subsidiaries in exchange for its centralised management of the activities of the group. Thus, in the light of the foregoing considerations, it must be held that the involvement of MVM in the management of its subsidiaries cannot be regarded as an ‘economic activity’ and MVM does not have the right to deduct the VAT paid for the services at issue.  That finding is not called into question by the fact that MVM engaged in other activities since the services at issue do not appear to have a direct and immediate link with any taxable economic activity.  If the referring court were to determine that some of the services at issue relate to both economic and non-economic activities it would be necessary to agree an appropriate method of apportionment.

The Court Order reads:

Articles 2, 9, 26, 167, 168 and 173 of Council Directive 2006/112/EC of 28 November 2006 on the common system of value added tax must be interpreted as meaning that, in so far as the involvement of a holding company, such as that at issue in the main proceedings, in the management of its subsidiaries, where it has charged those subsidiaries neither for the cost of the services procured in the interest of the group of companies as a whole or in the interest of certain of its subsidiaries, nor for the corresponding VAT, does not constitute an ‘economic activity’, within the meaning of that directive, such a holding company does not have the right to deduct input VAT paid in respect of those services in so far as those services relate to transactions falling outside the scope of that directive.

The CJEU’s Order clarifies that a holding company engaged in the management of its subsidiaries must effectively charge for its management services.  Where there is no charge, the involvement of the holding company in the managements of its subsidiaries cannot be regarded as an economic activity and VAT deduction should be restricted in this regard, unless there is a link to the business activity as a whole in which case deduction may still be possible where the costs relate to economic activities. Whether inter-company accruals, for example, may be acceptable as evidence of a ‘charge’ is yet to be tested.

!NEW!

HMRC has released its latest guidance on VAT recovery for holding companies.

In summary, the latest guidance confirms that in order to recover VAT on costs, a holding company must:

  • undertake a business activity for VAT purposes
  • be the recipient of the supply
  • be VAT registered/registerable at the time the cost is incurred, and
  • the costs must have a direct and immediate link with the holding company’s taxable supplies.

However, a right to deduct VAT on costs may exist even where there is no direct and immediate link between a particular input transaction and an output transaction, where those costs have a direct and immediate link with the business activity of the holding company, or VAT group, as a whole.

As best practice, taxable management services should be charged on to, and paid for by, the companies benefiting from the services. In practice, this is not always commercially possible so charities concerned with the potential changes may wish to review the position, while also considering other tax consequences.

Positives of the latest holding company guidance

  • Previous guidance released in September 2014 laid down a 5 to 10 year time limit for recovery of acquisition costs – this has been removed.
  • On stewardship costs, the HMRC guidance is helpful in confirming that VAT should be recoverable as long as the holding company has some sort of economic activity.
  • The HMRC guidance states that acquisition costs of shares purchased to support trading activities may be recoverable whether or not there are management supplies, loans, etc. This is very welcome and appears to reduce the scope of any HMRC challenge for “corporate” acquisitions.
  • Where no management activity exists because the holding company has a passive shareholding, any input tax restriction should be based on use rather than the simple number of passive shareholdings in the group
  • In looking at whether the holding company is the recipient of the supply, the guidance talks about who has contracted for the work, who is invoiced for and paid for the work and does not mention commissioning of the work. This is a positive step forward.
  • HMRC accept that where management services or interest bearing loans are provided by the holding company to VAT grouped subsidiaries, these activities can support the taxable supplies made to third parties by the VAT group, and so related input VAT may be deductible.

Potential challenges

  • HMRC set out in the background to the guidance that one basic function of a holding company is to dispose of shares in a subsidiary, and that such an activity is not an economic activity. In fact, a holding company may have no intention of disposing of shares in a subsidiary, but even if it did such an action could be economic, even though it may be exempt from VAT.
  • The guidance states that management services must be genuine and more than nominal but does not clarify what nominal means.
  • The guidance does not seem to recognise VAT groups as a single taxable person. The intention to isolate one member of a VAT group and consider whether its intra VAT group activities are economic is not consistent with the historic treatment of intra VAT group supplies being disregarded for VAT purposes.
  • HMRC does not make the VAT recovery position clear when a holding company acquires dormant subsidiaries held further down the group i.e. is VAT recovery still possible if taxable management services are provided to all directly held subsidiaries?
  • HMRC has tried to draw a distinction between corporate and private equity transactions, the former not necessarily requiring an economic activity by the holding company itself. This may require further clarification from HMRC to explain precise circumstances where VAT recovery is permitted.

HMRC’s guidance is, therefore, in line with the MVM decision and, as I previously concluded, it is important that holding companies who are involved in the management of their subsidiaries effectively charge the members of the group for those management services. If you are partly exempt for VAT purposes (a point which is particularly relevant in the charitable sector) then you should consider what impact a management charge may have on your Partial Exemption position.

Comments

  1. JeromeCoalm says:

    alo 789 dang nh?p: 789alo – dang nh?p alo789

  2. GeorgeAdect says:

    canadian pharmacy prices: certified canada pharmacy online – canadapharmacyonline legit

  3. Jamesbub says:

    canadian neighbor pharmacy: certified canada pharmacy online – canadian pharmacy online

  4. MonteSmure says:

    canadian pharmacy victoza legitimate canadian pharmacies online canadian drug pharmacy

  5. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.shop/# cheapest online pharmacy india

  6. GeorgeAdect says:

    pharmacy in canada: Cheapest online pharmacy – reddit canadian pharmacy

  7. ArthurSaulk says:

    http://mexicanpharminter.com/# MexicanPharmInter
    canadian pharmacy tampa

  8. Jamesbub says:

    canadian medications: highest rated canadian online pharmacy – canadian pharmacy in canada

  9. Willisgal says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.shop/# Mexican Pharm International

  10. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.shop/# reliable mexican pharmacies
    buy prescription drugs from canada cheap

  11. GeorgeAdect says:

    IndiaMedFast: online medicine shopping in india – india pharmacy without prescription

  12. MonteSmure says:

    Mexican Pharm International mexican pharmacy online store mexican pharmacy online order

  13. Jamesbub says:

    pharmacy canadian superstore: certified canada pharmacy online – canadian pharmacy prices

  14. Willisgal says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.com/# reliable mexican pharmacies

  15. ArthurSaulk says:

    http://mexicanpharminter.com/# reliable mexican pharmacies
    canadian world pharmacy

  16. GeorgeAdect says:

    canadapharmacyonline legit: Cheapest online pharmacy – canadian drug

  17. Jamesbub says:

    canada discount pharmacy: Cheapest online pharmacy – canadian compounding pharmacy

  18. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.shop/# IndiaMedFast.com

  19. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://indiamedfast.com/# IndiaMedFast
    medication canadian pharmacy

  20. MonteSmure says:

    cheap canadian pharmacy most reliable canadian online pharmacies legal canadian pharmacy online

  21. Jamesbub says:

    mexican drug stores online: mexican pharmacy online – buying from online mexican pharmacy

  22. Willisgal says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.com/# MexicanPharmInter

  23. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://interpharmonline.shop/# reliable canadian pharmacy
    77 canadian pharmacy

  24. HowardNag says:

    canadian pharmacy 24: Inter Pharm Online – canadian pharmacy ratings

  25. MonteSmure says:

    buying prescription drugs from india india online pharmacy store online medicine shopping in india

  26. Willisgal says:

    https://interpharmonline.shop/# canada rx pharmacy

  27. Jamesbub says:

    reliable mexican pharmacies: mexican drug stores online – Mexican Pharm Inter

  28. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://indiamedfast.shop/# order medicines online india
    my canadian pharmacy rx

  29. HowardNag says:

    canadian pharmacy 1 internet online drugstore: InterPharmOnline – ordering drugs from canada

  30. Willisgal says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican pharmacy online order

  31. ArthurSaulk says:

    http://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican pharmacy online store
    online canadian pharmacy reviews

  32. Jamesbub says:

    mexican pharmacy online: Mexican Pharm International – mexican pharmacy online order

  33. Dwaynethine says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com Tadalafil Easy Buy Tadalafil Easy Buy

  34. Terrynom says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# cialis without a doctor prescription

  35. Williamaxowl says:

    Tadalafil Easy Buy: cialis without a doctor prescription – TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  36. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# Generic 100mg Easy

  37. GregorypeF says:

    kamagra kopen nederland: kamagra jelly kopen – kamagra kopen nederland

  38. Terrynom says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# Tadalafil Easy Buy

  39. Williamaxowl says:

    Generic100mgEasy: Generic100mgEasy – Generic 100mg Easy

  40. Dwaynethine says:

    cialis without a doctor prescription Buy Tadalafil 5mg Tadalafil Tablet

  41. GregorypeF says:

    buy generic 100mg viagra online: buy generic 100mg viagra online – buy generic 100mg viagra online

  42. Terrynom says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic 100mg Easy

  43. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  44. Williamaxowl says:

    Tadalafil Easy Buy: Cialis 20mg price – cialis without a doctor prescription

  45. GregorypeF says:

    Tadalafil Easy Buy: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – Tadalafil Easy Buy

  46. Dwaynethine says:

    Cheap generic Viagra Generic100mgEasy buy generic 100mg viagra online

  47. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://generic100mgeasy.com/# Cheap Sildenafil 100mg

  48. Williamaxowl says:

    Generic Cialis price: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – Cialis 20mg price

  49. GregorypeF says:

    KamagraKopen.pro: Kamagra Kopen – KamagraKopen.pro

  50. Terrynom says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Cialis without a doctor prescription

  51. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Cheap Cialis

  52. Williamaxowl says:

    Generic 100mg Easy: buy generic 100mg viagra online – Generic 100mg Easy

  53. Dwaynethine says:

    Kamagra Kopen Kamagra Kopen Online Kamagra Kopen Online

  54. GregorypeF says:

    buy generic 100mg viagra online: Generic 100mg Easy – Generic100mgEasy

  55. Terrynom says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic100mgEasy

  56. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# Generic 100mg Easy

  57. Williamaxowl says:

    kamagra kopen nederland: Officiele Kamagra van Nederland – Kamagra

  58. GregorypeF says:

    Generic100mgEasy: buy generic 100mg viagra online – Generic 100mg Easy

  59. Terrynom says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Viagra generic over the counter

  60. Williamaxowl says:

    Generic100mgEasy: Cheap generic Viagra online – Viagra without a doctor prescription Canada

  61. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra pillen kopen

  62. Dwaynethine says:

    buy generic 100mg viagra online sildenafil 50 mg price buy generic 100mg viagra online

  63. Williamaxowl says:

    Kamagra Kopen Online: Officiele Kamagra van Nederland – kamagra gel kopen

  64. Terrynom says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra jelly kopen

  65. GregorypeF says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com: cialis without a doctor prescription – Tadalafil Easy Buy

  66. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  67. Williamaxowl says:

    Buy Tadalafil 20mg: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  68. Terrynom says:

    https://generic100mgeasy.com/# buy generic 100mg viagra online

  69. GregorypeF says:

    Viagra online price: Generic 100mg Easy – Generic100mgEasy

  70. Dwaynethine says:

    Generic100mgEasy Generic100mgEasy Generic100mgEasy

  71. Terrynom says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# KamagraKopen.pro

  72. Williamaxowl says:

    Generic 100mg Easy: buy generic 100mg viagra online – Generic 100mg Easy

  73. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# cialis without a doctor prescription

  74. GregorypeF says:

    Kamagra: kamagra 100mg kopen – Kamagra Kopen Online

  75. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen Online

  76. Dwaynethine says:

    Kamagra Kopen kamagra 100mg kopen Kamagra Kopen Online

  77. Williamaxowl says:

    buy generic 100mg viagra online: best price for viagra 100mg – Generic100mgEasy

  78. GregorypeF says:

    buy generic 100mg viagra online: Generic 100mg Easy – Generic100mgEasy

  79. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап вход – пин ап вход

  80. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап казино: https://pinupkz.life/

  81. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап казино – пинап казино

  82. JamesVal says:

    пин ап казино официальный сайт – пин ап казино официальный сайт

  83. Dwaynethine says:

    generic sildenafil Generic 100mg Easy buy generic 100mg viagra online

  84. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап: https://pinupkz.life/

  85. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап казино: https://pinupkz.life/

  86. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап зеркало – пин ап зеркало

  87. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап вход: https://pinupkz.life/

  88. Dwaynethine says:

    Generic 100mg Easy buy generic 100mg viagra online Generic100mgEasy

  89. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап казино – пинап казино

  90. JamesVal says:

    пин ап казино – пин ап

  91. Jessenuh says:

    pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/

  92. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап вход – пин ап вход

  93. Dwaynethine says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com Tadalafil Easy Buy cialis without a doctor prescription

  94. Jessenuh says:

    pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/

  95. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап – пин ап казино

  96. JamesVal says:

    пин ап – пин ап вход

  97. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап зеркало – пин ап зеркало

  98. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап зеркало: https://pinupkz.life/

  99. JamesVal says:

    pinup 2025 – пин ап вход

  100. Dwaynethine says:

    Generic Tadalafil 20mg price Tadalafil Easy Buy Cialis 20mg price

  101. Michaelsip says:

    Apoteket online: apotek online recept – apotek online recept

  102. Derekscory says:

    Kamagra Original: Kamagra Gel – kamagra

  103. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotheekmax.com/# ApotheekMax

  104. Malcolmtut says:

    apotek online recept apotek pa nett apotek online

  105. Michaelsip says:

    Kamagra Gel: Kamagra kaufen – Kamagra online bestellen

  106. Derekscory says:

    online apotheek: Apotheek Max – Apotheek Max

  107. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotheekmax.com/# Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept

  108. HomerCob says:

    https://apotheekmax.shop/# Beste online drogist

  109. Derekscory says:

    Kamagra Original: Kamagra online bestellen – Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept

  110. Michaelsip says:

    Kamagra kaufen: Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept – Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept

  111. Louisbeece says:

    http://apotekonlinerecept.com/# apotek pa nett

  112. Malcolmtut says:

    de online drogist kortingscode Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept online apotheek

  113. HomerCob says:

    https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apotek hemleverans idag

  114. Derekscory says:

    Apotek hemleverans recept: Apoteket online – Apotek hemleverans recept

  115. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotheekmax.shop/# Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept

  116. Michaelsip says:

    de online drogist kortingscode: Apotheek Max – Apotheek Max

  117. HomerCob says:

    https://apotheekmax.com/# Online apotheek Nederland met recept

  118. Louisbeece says:

    http://apotheekmax.com/# Beste online drogist

  119. Derekscory says:

    apotek online recept: apotek online – apotek online

  120. Malcolmtut says:

    de online drogist kortingscode online apotheek Apotheek Max

  121. Michaelsip says:

    Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept: online apotheek – ApotheekMax

  122. Louisbeece says:

    http://apotheekmax.com/# Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept

  123. Derekscory says:

    Apotheek Max: Apotheek online bestellen – Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept

  124. Michaelsip says:

    kamagra: Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen – Kamagra online bestellen

  125. Malcolmtut says:

    apotek online recept apotek pa nett Apoteket online

  126. Derekscory says:

    apotek online recept: apotek online – apotek online recept

  127. HomerCob says:

    http://kamagrapotenzmittel.com/# Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *