Gift Aid qualifying donations and application of HMRC guidance – the Champions Fun Learning Centre case
The First-tier Tribunal decision in the Champions Fun Learning Centre case illustrates how difficult it can be to understand and apply the Gift Aid rules and HMRC’s guidance. The decision has disappointingly little analysis of the Gift Aid rules and guidance, but is notable for the interesting facts and the unorthodox approach taken by the Tribunal in its decision-making.
The First-tier Tribunal considered various assessments, with interest and penalties, issued by HMRC in respect of the Champions Fun Learning Centre (the Charity). Payments were made by parents and others in respect of education programmes provided by the Charity. The Charity also benefited where volunteers either returned or failed to cash cheques for their expenses. HMRC alleged the payments/waivers were not qualifying donations for Gift Aid and that the Charity had been careless in claiming Gift Aid. The Tribunal found all the assessments to be invalid (being “riddled with errors” which were too fundamental and too misleading to enable the assessments to stand). Nevertheless the Tribunal considered HMRC’s arguments regarding the Charity’s Gift Aid claims.
The issues considered in this commentary are:
- Whether the payments made to the Charity were gifts at all.
- Whether, if they were gifts, the conditions for them to be qualifying donations were complied with as to (i) refunds or (ii) benefits above the limits.
- Whether the volunteers’ donations of their entitlement to expenses were qualifying donations.
- Whether the Charity had been careless in making its Gift Aid claims (such as to give rise to a penalty).
The Tribunal also considered other issues relating to the Charity’s constitution, a double payment of Gift Aid relief and, in detail, the validity of the assessments and penalty, which are not considered here.
(1) Were the payments gifts?
The Charity’s constitution provided that “Every parent shall pay the [Charity] a monthly sum …”. FAQs on its website made reference to “fees” “donation stipulations”, “fixed donations” and potential refunds. The PayPal donations page started “Purpose: Parent Contribution/Fees”.
HMRC argued that these references meant that the payments were not voluntary contributions but payments for a service and not eligible for Gift Aid. They also argued that “donors” had had the same understanding, based on 4 responses to a questionnaire which HMRC had sent to a sample (10%) of the donors.
The Charity argued that they had sought to follow HMRC’s guidance on membership schemes about under 18s, that not all contributions were made by parents/guardians and that 15% of parents did not make donations.
The Tribunal gave some weight to the questionnaire responses showing that parents thought they were paying a monthly sum for tuition of their children. The decision then sets out lengthy extracts from HMRC guidance on Gift Aid, first the passages relating to membership subscriptions (in response to the Charity’s claim to follow that part of the guidance) and then the paragraphs relating to educational trusts.
The Tribunal decided that the Charity had misinterpreted a passage in the guidance (para 3.37.10) as meaning that any payment made by a parent or guardian for membership services provided to a minor will be a gift. (In fact, the passage is referring to paying other people’s subscriptions, saying that usually these would be a gift to the other person not to the charity, but can be a donation where the “other person” is the donor’s minor child, provided the payment would qualify as a gift if made by the donor personally). The Charity had, therefore, operated under a misapprehension regarding the guidance.
The Tribunal would at that point be expected to apply the law to the facts of the case to determine whether or not, notwithstanding the Charity’s misapprehension and the apparent view of some of the “donors”, the payments were in fact qualifying donations. Unfortunately, no such analysis follows. Instead, the Tribunal appears to have applied the HMRC guidance relating to education trusts, rather than the law, to the situation before it. To the extent that it did so, the approach must be wrong.
Having taken that approach, the Tribunal’s view (apparent from later in the decision) was that only the parental payments were capable of being disqualified as donations, but it was not prepared to say which ones failed on the information before it.
Given the facts, there was a real opportunity here for an important decision analysing such factors as: the wording used by the Charity in describing the payments; the practical impact of whether or not a payment was made (e.g. if tuition was provided whether or not any individual donation was made and whether a child was permitted to attend if no payment had been made on their behalf, which seemed to be the case); whether the Charity was operating a membership scheme; testing HMRC’s guidance relating to educational trusts; application of the donor benefit rules. Unfortunately, that opportunity has been missed.
(2)(i) Refunds
The Charity’s website FAQs provided, in response to a question whether there would be a “refund of fees paid or any donations made” if a child was unable to attend due to illness or emergency, that “if it is possible to offer a refund, we will”. HMRC contended that this meant that there was a condition as to repayment preventing the payment from being a qualifying donation.
The Tribunal disagreed, finding that “the possibility of a refund of itself” was not such a condition. However, as would be expected, the Tribunal agreed that any payments that were in fact refunded would not be gifts.
(2)(ii) Donor benefits
HMRC argued that a benefit (education) was received here by an associated person (the child of the donor) and was received “in consequence of” the donation. They argued that the small benefits rule was broken because the donor payments were £5 to £8 a week whereas the cost of providing the tuition was £25 to £30.
The Charity sought to argue that it was the other way round and the benefit was only about 16% of the value of the services provided (presumably on the basis that the service was not individual tuition, but tuition provided as a whole with all attendees benefiting).
The Tribunal took HMRC’s part, agreeing that provision of the tuition was a benefit where the donation was made by a parent (as the child would be an associated person), but found that the same may not be true where the payment was made by a guardian, depending then upon whether the child is “connected” within the legislative definition (s417 ITA 2007, read with s993 and s994(1)). The Tribunal also determined that the value of the benefit in this case was the cost to the Charity of providing the service (although it said that this was “absent any other suggestion”) and that the size of the benefit was not to exceed a percentage of the donation (not the other way around).
Again, this appears to be a direct application of HMRC’s guidance relating to “educational trusts” with little or no analysis of the application of the law to the facts or, indeed, of other parts of HMRC’s guidance. There is, for example, no analysis relating to valuing donor benefit or the application of the “in consequence” rule. It seems that other argument on these points was not heard.
(3) Volunteer waivers
HMRC submitted that it was not sufficient for volunteers to refuse or fail to cash their expenses for such amounts to be qualifying donations. Rather, a “payment” of a “sum of money” required a physical payment from the Charity to the volunteer, which the volunteer may then choose to give back, or an exchange of cheques. The Tribunal dismissed this as “picking at nits” and, had it been relevant, would have upheld the Charity’s contention that the volunteers’ waivers were qualifying donations.
In the Tribunal’s view, the crucial point was that the Charity was liable to pay the expenses. However, traditionally, release of a debt has not been treated as payment of a sum of money. A First-tier tribunal decision does not create a binding legal precedent, so charities may want to be wary of relying upon it.
(4) Carelessness
The Tribunal found that the Charity had not been careless in making its claim. It had been “conscientious in examining HMRC’s website in relation to membership schemes and other matters” and the fact that it came to an incorrect view did not mean it was careless of the Charity to come to that view.
The case certainly underlines that the Gift Aid rules are complex, difficult to navigate and easy to get wrong (including, as in this case, by HMRC) and that HMRC’s guidance on the rules can be difficult to navigate. Unfortunately, the decision, which could have provided a great deal of clarity on the application of the rules, fails to do so and, in the apparent reliance of the Tribunal on guidance rather than the law, raises cause for concern.
Nicola Evans is Charities Counsel at Bircham Dyson Bell LLP
Comments
Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with SEO?
I’m trying to get my site to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results.
If you know of any please share. Thank you! I saw similar
text here: Eco product
Rabat is the capital metropolis of Morocco.
sugar defender official website Uncovering Sugar Protector
has been a game-changer for me, as I have actually always been vigilant
concerning managing my blood sugar level degrees. With this
supplement, I really feel empowered to organize my health, and my most current
medical examinations have actually reflected a considerable turn-around.
Having a credible ally in my edge gives me with a complacency and confidence, and I’m deeply
appreciative for the extensive difference Sugar Defender has made in my wellness.
You’ve made some decent points there. I checked on the internet for additional information about the issue and found most people will go along with your views on this website.
An outstanding share! I have just forwarded this onto a coworker who has been doing a little research on this. And he in fact ordered me dinner because I found it for him… lol. So allow me to reword this…. Thanks for the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending the time to discuss this issue here on your site.
When I originally left a comment I appear to have clicked on the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now whenever a comment is added I get four emails with the exact same comment. There has to be a way you are able to remove me from that service? Cheers.
There’s certainly a lot to know about this topic. I really like all of the points you made.
I love it when folks come together and share thoughts. Great site, stick with it.
I need to to thank you for this good read!! I certainly enjoyed every little bit of it. I’ve got you book marked to check out new stuff you post…
카지노 사이트 추천을 원하시는 분들께, 추천하는 최고의 게임 사이트를 알려드리겠습니다. 에볼루션 카지노에서 안전하고 게임 경험을 경험해보세요.
whoah this weblog is excellent i love studying your posts. Keep up the good work! You recognize, many individuals are looking around for this info, you could help them greatly.
Great information. Lucky me I came across your website by accident (stumbleupon). I’ve saved as a favorite for later.
문카지노에서 출금이 편리한 사이트 구해요.
Good day! I simply want to offer you a big thumbs up for the great information you’ve got right here on this post. I’ll be returning to your website for more soon.
Starting a venture can be overwhelming, but with the right resource, you can accelerate your launch. This comprehensive guide provides advice on how to develop a successful startup and mitigate common pitfalls. Check out this link for further information and to learn more about unlocking growth.
What an informative entry! I gained tons from perusing it. Your information is highly structured and straightforward to follow.
This is great. I gained a lot from perusing it. The information is extremely informative and well-organized.
Truly appreciated reading this entry. It’s very articulate and filled with helpful details. Many thanks for sharing this.
Appreciated the information in this entry. It’s extremely detailed and filled with beneficial details. Excellent effort!
Positioned in the most prime areas of Crete, these luxurious villas provide the perfect environment for an extraordinary retreat. Find your perfect escape.
Nice article this is going to help my chinese mandarin tutoring service!
Going to use this for my SEO agency!
Thsi will help with my chinese online tutoring lessons.
Thsi will help with my Google Entity Stacking service.
Thsi will help with my Google Entity Stacking service.
Thsi will help with my Google Entity Stacking service.
Thsi will help with my Google Entity Stacking service.
Thsi will help with my Estrogen Blocker Supplements!
Thsi will help with my Estrogen Blocker Supplements!
It is because I began enjoying laptop games, and taking part in them in a sure approach, and combining this with a certain sort of e-book study.
This page was last edited on 24 May 2024, at 12:29 (UTC).
Thsi will help with my Estrogen Blocker Supplements!
To better perceive each step in the tech startup accelerator course of, let’s use the instance of Y Combinator, a model for Silicon Valley accelerators.
Thsi will help with my Estrogen Blocker Supplements!
In whole life or variable life insurance policy, the part of the premium goes for funding fund whereas in term life insurance coverage, no part of the premium is used for investment purposes and in brief, the premiums in this policy pays the insured.
A redrawn model of the arms of the monastery of Christ Church, London can be seen as part of the on-line version of the 1894 e book A Glossary of Terms Utilized in Heraldry by James Parker.
What gets left out of this story is the fact that — like most Apple products, like most presidents — the anticipation of a product release can easily overshadow any actual value.
Thsi will help with my Estrogen Blocker Supplements!
Delivered quickly. Practical.
Fantastic. Worth every penny. Helped as expected.
thanks for this article!
thanks for this article!
Use of tether stable coin on ETH underwent a small change moving from Asian Business Hours to US and European business hours which might be a result of the recent crackdown by the Chinese authorities on the trading of cryptocurrencies and USDT’s users migrating from ETH to other blockchains.
thanks for this article!
thanks for this article!
thanks for this article!
A real traditional from the ’50s, the 300 SL started life as a racing automotive in 1952 but quickly turned a manufacturing automotive in 1954 as a two-door coupe.
Previous to putting in the wire, it’s possible you’ll want to format your boundary with both spray paint or a backyard hose.
thanks for this article!
This won’t be true, however would you want to danger a profession in straightforward to automate manufacturing unit work when you possibly can pursue a career in tech that may mean you experience the wave of future jobs?
It was the largest Japanese defeat up to that time.
They impart an elegant look when worn and portals have them shipped to you in a bag that’s tamper proof.
thanks for this article!
He played his remaining 2018-19 campaign with ATK, and played his first match with ATK that season against Kerala Blasters on 25 January 2019, which ended in a 1-1 draw.
Excellent product. Really, highly recommend.
One way of investing in commodities is placed trading.
Listed here are some examples of successful entrepreneurs in India.
Need more cheesetastic favorites to fulfill your cravings, try the hyperlinks on the next web page.
thanks for this article!
More practical than I expected! Amazing.
Choosing BitMEX trading combined with trading bots and margin trading can be perfect and safer in all ways.
One question you might have is: How does a privately held company establish a market and grant (strike) price on each share of its stock?
The Lenape had settlements on the river, including Nittabakonck (“place the place heroes reside”), a village on the east bank simply south of the confluence of Wissahickon Creek, and the Passyunk site, on the west bank the place the Schuylkill meets the Delaware River.
Furthermore, many gothic clothing shops in the USA prioritize ethical and sustainable practices, making certain which you can specific your alternative fashion whereas supporting responsible vogue choices.
Darth Revan – Historical Dark Lord of the Sith mentioned in the Rise of Skywalker: The Visible Dictionary, because the namesake of the third Legion of Sith Troopers from Darth Sidious’ Sith Eternal cult.
15 February – Minister for Health Stephen Donnelly confirmed areas for 37 vaccination centres across all counties as a part of the nation’s COVID-19 vaccination programme.
Nov 8-9, 2024. Countryside, IL.
The kiosks at San Francisco airport are named as Local weather Passport Kiosks.
The rest of the players shall be ants.
The future treasury secretary “played a central role in casting the Philadelphia Mutiny as a greater danger to the young republic than it was, thus advancing his demand for a strong, central government with police powers over its domain, i.e., not subject to any state’s authority,” explains J.D.
I’m attempting to remain positive however worrying about the outcome.
Through the winter months, guests come to this park to ski, snowboard, and tube on its many slopes.
Genuinely enjoyed reading this article. It’s highly well-written and filled with valuable information. Thanks for offering this.
The report “Global food and beverage metal cans market by raw materials, sizes and shapes, applications, price trends and forecast, 2011-2016” defines and segments the global food and beverage metal cans market with analysis and forecasting of the global revenues for metal cans.
This is extremely enlightening. I truly appreciated going through it. The details is very structured and easy to understand.
Adored the information in this post. It’s very comprehensive and packed with beneficial information. Fantastic work!
Bonds can supply strong yields in nearly any market state of affairs, so most fund managers include them in the combination.
As you seek for lowest refinance charges associated info or other data per low price refinance or refinance mortgage charges, take a bit time to view the beneath article.
The associated fee of those plates are the identical as the regular problem.
The obtained association rules can be further assessed to find different conditions and features that coincide on a large block of information.
Enter John Browning. Browning already had a reputation as an innovative gun maker when he set out to improve the semiautomatic pistol, but his .45-caliber design for Colt set a new standard.
She was a retired schoolteacher, retired director of Arkansas Department of Human Providers, proprietor of cash and Carry Grocery and member of First United Methodist Church, Ben Lomond.
There are additionally a lot ways to meet different single parents naturally, whether by means of becoming a member of a membership or enrolling in courses.