First experience of submitting a Common Reporting Standard (CRS) return
The deadline for submitting Automatic Exchange of Information (AEOI) returns (under the Common Reporting Standard rules) for the year ended 31 December 2016, was 31 May 2017.
CTG has worked with charitable trusts to help them understand whether they need to undertake these reporting requirements and has encouraged feedback from members on their experiences with this first submission.
One charity representative has told us:
“We have just successfully submitted a CRS return online on behalf of our organisation, which administers a number of different charities. Across the organisation, we have probably invested about 20 work days into this. After review, we had 16 Charities that were identified as Financial Institutions. After due diligence was carried out, only 1 of these had made payments to a reportable jurisdiction. This was a single donation payment of 1,220 euros to a charity based in a reportable jurisdiction – so all of this effort for about £1,000 of grant funding.
“Overall, we found HMRC’s Offshore Data Exchange Team (ODET) to be very helpful and supportive. They were available to talk us through what were probably basic questions at any time, and always came back promptly to emails. Their responses were jargon free, and were sympathetic to how matters related to charities.
“The HMRC online team were not helpful at all with CRS. We had to call them when there were problems with my online account set-up. They insisted that we had to provide a PAYE number to them, to enable them to help us, and were unable to understand when we explained that my tiny charity that had to report under CRS did not have one of these. They also insisted that I provide a FATCA number, and were not aware that charities had been exempt from this. My only solution was to talk with the ODET office – who were very frustrated to hear how the HMRC Online office were responding. It was as a result of their help behind the scenes that we were able to sort out the issue with my online account.
“In making the submission, we had to phone the ODET office 3 times, as the language used within the online submission process was not relevant to charities so not clear to me how to complete. At each time, the staff were very helpful, and talked me through how to respond. They were clearly well versed as to how to assist charities, and were able to make sensible suggestions.
“In conclusion:
- This has taken up an inordinate amount of staff resource
- It has caused anger within some of the charities we administer, as they did not wish to approach grantees who had received small amounts to confirm their tax status
- Despite the additional guidance made available for charities, it was not easy to relate processes to charitable activities
- HMRC online staff had little idea how to support charities with this process
- Staff at the ODET office in Cardiff were brilliant.
“We are pleased to have met the deadline and now feel better prepared for next year, but think improvements could be made to the guidance for charities and further consideration should be given to whether the additional administrative burden caused by the due diligence process is required. The introduction of a de-minimis value would be very useful – even if just set at £100.”
While another charity has commented:
“Following a late night submission I am sorry to report that the whole process was more complex than anticipated, compounded by the fact that the submission website was suffering technical difficulties on the afternoon of deadline day.
“My first observation on the process is that there is no indication on HMRC’s website as to what is actually needed to complete the online return. The first chance of seeing what is needed is when you start to enter actual live details. Providing this information on the website would help to save a lot of time in future.
“The return also required a lot more data than we were led to believe from earlier discussions with the officials responsible for CRS which meant that I had not got all the information required in one place. For example, it had never been made clear in what currency you would have to report grant payments and balances so it varies as to how we have offered the grant (or does it?). Applying the $250k threshold for existing accounts to multiple currencies was also a nightmare as a result. Furthermore, questions are obviously aimed at the likes of banks holding client accounts with a choice of drop down answers that are irrelevant to grant making charities.
“Following the due diligence process and having filtered through over 1,000 grants we determined that we had 45 grant holders to enter -as this had to be done one at a time it took about 4 hours to complete.
“We have not yet worked out the total time to complete the submission, but it has involved:
- 3 people from our IT department to set up systems to interrogate different databases.
- 3 people drafting appropriate letters to go out to different classes of grantees. Approximately 600 were sent out, each of which had to be approved by the grant handler.
- Finance and grant management departments having to be briefed on what was going on and how to respond to queries
- Recording the grantee responses to our letters (none of our databases are designed to record this so it has gone on a temporary worksheet until we pay someone to redesign the data capture process)
- Sense checking responses and sending further requests when respondents had not identified which type of entity they were. Invariably it is not our contact (the grant recipient) in an organisation that can answer the questions we are asking about their organisation’s entity type as defined for CRS purposes.
“It would be no exaggeration to estimate the time to date in man-months and this doesn’t include the time and costs still to be incurred in redesigning our database systems. Overall not the best use of charity time and resources.”
We would welcome feedback from you on whether you have been able to meet the 31 May 2017 deadline, and, what your experience has been of the due diligence and reporting process. Please send any comments to info@charitytaxgroup.org.uk. This feedback will then be shared with HMRC on an anonymous basis.
HMRC has indicated that if reasonable steps have and are being made by charities to comply with the CRS filing requirements, but it has not be possible to make the deadline, these charities should contact HMRC. We have been told that HMRC will apply a light touch approach where charities have made efforts to carry out due diligence requirements and report accurately, but this approach is contingent on early communication with HMRC. If a charity is still in any way uncertain as to its status in relation to the CRS, we would encourage them to seek professional advice and/or HMRC to make certain of their situation and any reporting requirements.
The Association of Charitable Foundations has compiled a useful summary of the steps affected charitable trusts need to take (charitable companies are not required to report as their grant recipients are not regarded as “Account holders”). HMRC’s detailed guidance for charities can be read here. Alana Petraske’s helpful blog outlining her top 10 tips for charities affected by CRS can be read here.
Comments
Howdy! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get
my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not
seeing very good results. If you know of any please share.
Thanks! You can read similar blog here: Eco bij
In the subsequent part we’ll learn about an acute sense that you just actually may be glad to not have.
I enjoy reading through an article that can make men and women think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment.
Having read this I believed it was extremely informative. I appreciate you finding the time and effort to put this informative article together. I once again find myself personally spending a lot of time both reading and leaving comments. But so what, it was still worth it!
Nice post. I learn something new and challenging on sites I stumbleupon on a daily basis. It will always be helpful to read through content from other writers and use a little something from their web sites.
This site was… how do I say it? Relevant!! Finally I’ve found something that helped me. Thank you!
Very nice article. I certainly appreciate this site. Keep writing!
I was extremely pleased to discover this site. I wanted to thank you for your time for this particularly fantastic read!! I definitely loved every part of it and I have you saved as a favorite to look at new information on your site.
It’s difficult to find knowledgeable people for this topic, however, you seem like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks
I blog frequently and I genuinely thank you for your content. Your article has really peaked my interest. I will take a note of your blog and keep checking for new information about once per week. I opted in for your RSS feed too.
bookmarked!!, I love your website.
I blog quite often and I truly appreciate your content. Your article has really peaked my interest. I’m going to bookmark your blog and keep checking for new information about once per week. I opted in for your Feed too.
You’ve made some good points there. I looked on the web to learn more about the issue and found most people will go along with your views on this site.
gas grills can really make very tasty and juicy barbecue”
It’s difficult to find knowledgeable people about this subject, but you seem like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks
This is based on the notion that you will gain or lose 2 for every 1 change in the market.
However it also exhibits the intelligent use of design ideas that may work simply as effectively in a smaller room.
In a well-ventilated area, spray-paint the tombstone grey; let dry 20 to half-hour.
19.gxf3 Ba3 20.Kd2 Bb2 21.Re1 Nd5 and Black is winning.
At first, just one player can build into a metropolis, and it prices 10 Elektro (the game’s foreign money) to access a city.
EBay charges four types of fees to sellers: an insertion fee charged when you list your item, upgrades for enhancing your listings, a final value fee based on the selling price of your item, and fees for collecting payment through PayPal.
Not only family business narellan, but family business services all over the world are a kind of great boon to those people who had been a victim of financial crisis.
Faculty Knowledge for the Bordentown Regional College District, Nationwide Center for Training Statistics.
If you are trying to look for a way to understand the stock market and be successful, then you should definitely consider investing in a share market or stock market software.
The European Central Bank announced that it could purchase as much as €750 billion ($820 billion) of authorities and company bonds and industrial paper.
As for the type of content you produce for your channel depends in your audience and their wants.
The Blackberry phone permits its consumer to get pleasure from nice messaging as properly.
While Red is the popular shade for performing any Pooja and for the married ladies in major occasions, multicolored dresses equivalent to long Kurtis, Anarkali, gowns, and Maxi dresses are in and anyone pairing them with good equipment can dazzle the gang.
RED offers lessons that are flexible and can be customised to
fit your schedule, whether you need weekly sessions or
a more accelerated learning plan.
Characters sometimes recommended missions or subquests, but just as usually ended up being filler we had been reluctant to cut, though their missions or story functions changed throughout our storyline-focusing passes.
Why are Electric Cars so Expensive?
A monetary consultant will consult the individual to evaluate current money related conditions and create a plan that reaches the goal undoubtedly.
Kirka, Danica; Lee, Youkyung (June 24, 2016).
CARTA operates 17 routes, together with a free electric shuttle service in the downtown space, and free wireless Internet on sure “smartbuses”.
The truth is that you do not know what you do not know and so life should be revealed slightly at a time.
Which Are The Top Trending Highly Paid Jobs in India?
Different natural wonders and native ruins, Route 66, and its astronomical history also carry tourism from out of state, while people from further south in Arizona go to Flagstaff because of its cooler local weather in the summer and its ski resort in the winter.
The position of the Chief Operational Risk Officer (CORO) continues to evolve and gain significance.
These states not solely lead in median household earnings but in addition contribute considerably to the general economic development and success of the nation.
Carter, Alice T. “Strip District shop tailors each cup of java to buyer.” Pittsburgh Tribune-Assessment.
To get it out of the bone, chefs use a marrow spoon.
One popular sort — surge breaks — work automatically.
The time-frame may be 1 day time, week, month or even a few years.
No matter you do, don’t permit yourself to feel responsible for being a working guardian and having a family.
In brief, the monetary transmission mechanism will be outlined as the hyperlink between monetary coverage and aggregate demand.
You need to have online savings account for growing money faster.
Loved this!
For those who do private a second property that you could be give you, as an example one more business home or probably a residential house, then as a substitute of risking the entire home, a mortgage mortgage mortgage supplier can elevate modest charge in the direction of element on the residence.
Created the Lebanon County Gleaning Community, which coordinates with local growers to distribute excess fruit and vegetable harvests to needy individuals and families.
But so far, no one has come up with an enormous recreation changer: Nearly a billion folks routinely go undernourished in any given yr.
However lately, robbers have taken as a lot as $1 billion in a single 12 months without ever drawing a gun or looking a single customer in the eye.