Commentary on Revenue & Customs Brief 10 (2022)
On 1st June HMRC published what it called a “policy paper”, incorporated within Revenue & Customs Brief 10 (2022). The subject title of the paper is “business and non-business activities”. A title of that kind suggests, not only a subject of relevance to charities, but a very meaty subject in itself.
However, the ensuing text (which was not sent to CTG for comment or review prior to publication) does not suggest a detailed or sufficiently thorough analysis. The first comment to make is that it only covers one aspect of the business/non-business subject, namely the one generally associated with scale and regularity. It does not cover the question of whether a sum of money or other valued benefit received by a charity is in consideration for a supply, or, alternatively, a grant/donation for the general good, or the receipt of a levy (as can arise with a trade body). The title should have made clear that it does not cover these aspects, whereas someone reading this policy paper could assume that it does, and could accordingly be misled into thinking that regular receipt of grants, for instance, amounted to a business activity.
But that, unfortunately, is not where the difficulties end.
One of its main apparent purposes is to withdraw a longstanding HMRC policy, which was that childcare charities, providing nursery or creche facilities, are not involved in a business activity. It certainly refers to a change of policy, rather than merely seeking to provide information as to HMRC’s existing policy, and it is welcome that they are explicit enough in saying that a change has occurred. What it does not do, however, is provide a date from which the policy will be deemed to have been changed. All we have to go on is the 1st June date attributed to the Brief’s publication. That is unfortunate. An explicit date of change would have been preferable.
This point is important. The greatest relevance of the question relating to, for example, childcare charities, is as to whether their activities allow them to issue a certificate for the construction of a new building on a zero rated basis. Ideally, one would expect there to be a date up to which such a certificate would be regarded as valid, and not open to adjustment under the “clawback” rules. We also note that, as at 13th June, the HMRC manuals page enshrining their previous policy (VATEDU36900) had not been updated to reflect the abovementioned change. It is difficult to understand why the policy paper was issued with an explicit reference to a change of policy, without updating the public guidance on the withdrawn policy.
This cannot have been done in a hurry, since the case law which led HMRC to view that policy as no longer tenable, was a Court of Appeal decision in May 2018, more than four years prior to the date of the Brief.
When we consider the wider application of the contents of the Brief, matters become less clear still. The approach HMRC appears to have taken is to quote the judge-given law aspects of Court of Appeal decisions in the last five or six years, without explaining how in practise they intend to apply them. We are told that the familiar “Lord Fisher” tests, derived from decades old case law, are no longer applicable, and they have been replaced by a two stage test adumbrated by the Court of Appeal in 2018. But we are also told, at the same time, without apparent intention to contradict, that the original Lord Fisher tests can be used to assist in working out the answer in applying the more recent two stage test. The way in which this is presented amounts to something of a contradiction. If the old Lord Fisher tests have to be applied to another two stage test, it is a simple matter to say that that is how they will be applied, rather than saying that they are no longer to be applied. This could have been clarified at the drafting stage thereby avoiding a policy publication which appears internally contradictory.
But that would not be a major problem if we could understand what is really meant by the “two stage test”. This puts forward the view that, in order for an activity to be a business, there must be, both, consideration for a supply, and, that supply must be for remuneration. So, the two stages are first to consider whether there is consideration, and then to consider whether there is remuneration. Only if both apply is there a business. That is the same as saying that something is non-business if one or more of those two tests are failed.
And that is where the help ends, since there is no definition given of “remuneration”. “Consideration”, of course, has a legal meaning (it is a ‘term of art’), but “remuneration” is a more elusive concept. How can we tell whether activities that attract consideration are also for remuneration? It is difficult to see whether HMRC knows the answer to that question, since they do not appear to attempt to answer it. Not only do we not get any examples by way of illustration of where they might draw the line, but we do not even get a textual discussion of what they mean by what they say. They say that it arises where an activity is carried out “for the purpose of obtaining income”, but that is hardly revealing when we are explicitly told that the Lord Fisher test relating to “predominant concern” is no longer applicable. What kind of purpose are they referring to when considering the rationale for an activity? It cannot be the primary purpose, because that would also be the “predominant concern”. It must mean something different to that, but we are not told what it means.
They could justify this as being a consequence of the Court of Appeal decision also not telling us what was meant by what was said. However, that is unhelpful from the point of view of understanding government policy.
One is driven to the conclusion that there continues to be an important role for the Lord Fisher tests. Out of the six tests, the one that was roundly condemned in the Longridge on Thames litigation was that of “predominant concern”. But if we look at the others, which are to do with the manner in which the activity is conducted, its scale, frequency, or regularity, comparability with activities in the market, these are central Lord Fisher concepts. If we assume that activities that are carried out “for remuneration” must have a structure and intention behind them, which bespeaks a business-like attitude, reasonable frequency and regularity, and an intended degree of permanence, we are clearly in old fashioned Lord Fisher territory. Far from this bringing Lord Fisher to an end, all it does is hack off the part of Lord Fisher which clearly failed in the more recent litigation, namely the motive test of “predominant concern”.
But that is not what the Brief actually says. It is difficult to see professional advisers being able to advise on the basis of the Brief. Even more so, is it unlikely that a charity trustee or director could draw a sensible conclusion based on this policy paper. It is likely to disincentivise the use of the charity reliefs which are dependent upon this analysis, and to increase the traffic for the already overburdened enquiries staff of HMRC in dealing with queries as to whether an activity does or does not satisfy the two stage test. It is, in short, an inadequate policy paper, which ought to be fundamentally reviewed.
CTG intends to contact HMRC policy unit to raise these points formally, in the hope of being able to secure an improved policy communication.
Graham Elliott is Technical Adviser to the Charity Tax Group
Comments
yik5gi
qo96vf
yv309z
alo789hk: dang nh?p alo789 – alo789hk
my canadian pharmacy rx fda approved canadian online pharmacies trustworthy canadian pharmacy
best online canadian pharmacy: most reliable canadian online pharmacies – canada discount pharmacy
http://interpharmonline.com/# canadian pharmacy price checker
best canadian pharmacy to buy from
canadian pharmacy online: most reliable canadian online pharmacies – canadian family pharmacy
IndiaMedFast: online medicine shopping in india – online medicine shopping in india
https://indiamedfast.shop/# india online pharmacy store
canadian pharmacy
https://mexicanpharminter.shop/# mexican pharmacy online
legitimate canadian pharmacies: fda approved canadian online pharmacies – cheapest pharmacy canada
order medicines online india online pharmacy india lowest prescription prices online india
india pharmacy without prescription: India Med Fast – india online pharmacy store
https://indiamedfast.com/# online medicine shopping in india
canada drugstore pharmacy rx
https://interpharmonline.com/# canadian online pharmacy
buying prescription drugs from india: online medicine shopping in india – online pharmacy india
canadian 24 hour pharmacy: online canadian pharmacy no prescription – best canadian online pharmacy
https://indiamedfast.shop/# online medicine shopping in india
reliable canadian online pharmacy
india pharmacy without prescription IndiaMedFast IndiaMedFast
http://interpharmonline.com/# canadian family pharmacy
http://indiamedfast.com/# India Med Fast
best mail order pharmacy canada
canadian pharmacy reviews: canada pharmacy no prescription – thecanadianpharmacy
https://interpharmonline.shop/# canada pharmacy online
reliable mexican pharmacies mexican pharmacy online store Mexican Pharm Inter
order medicines online india: online medicine shopping in india – cheapest online pharmacy india
http://indiamedfast.com/# India Med Fast
canadian 24 hour pharmacy: Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US – certified canadian international pharmacy
http://mexicanpharminter.com/# Mexican Pharm Inter
canada drugstore pharmacy rx
https://interpharmonline.com/# canadadrugpharmacy com
reliable canadian online pharmacy: most trusted canadian pharmacies online – canada drugs reviews
MexicanPharmInter buying from online mexican pharmacy mexican drug stores online
cross border pharmacy canada: most reliable canadian online pharmacies – safe online pharmacies in canada
https://indiamedfast.com/# IndiaMedFast
canada drug pharmacy
https://indiamedfast.shop/# india online pharmacy store
cialis without a doctor prescription: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – Tadalafil Easy Buy
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# Sildenafil Citrate Tablets 100mg
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# Generic 100mg Easy
kamagra gel kopen: kamagra kopen nederland – kamagra gel kopen
Viagra generic over the counter Generic100mgEasy Buy Viagra online cheap
Viagra generic over the counter: Generic 100mg Easy – buy generic 100mg viagra online
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# buy generic 100mg viagra online
https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# Tadalafil Easy Buy
kamagra gel kopen: Kamagra Kopen – Kamagra
TadalafilEasyBuy.com: Tadalafil Easy Buy – п»їcialis generic
https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# cialis without a doctor prescription
KamagraKopen.pro Kamagra kamagra gel kopen
Tadalafil Easy Buy: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – Tadalafil price
cialis without a doctor prescription: cialis without a doctor prescription – TadalafilEasyBuy.com
https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen Online
kamagra kopen nederland kamagra 100mg kopen Officiele Kamagra van Nederland
cheapest cialis: cialis without a doctor prescription – Tadalafil Easy Buy
http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic 100mg Easy
kamagra gel kopen: kamagra pillen kopen – kamagra gel kopen
https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# cialis without a doctor prescription
Kamagra Kopen Online: Kamagra Kopen – Kamagra Kopen
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# Generic100mgEasy
cialis without a doctor prescription: Generic Cialis price – Tadalafil Easy Buy
https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra gel kopen
Tadalafil Easy Buy: cialis without a doctor prescription – Tadalafil Easy Buy
cialis without a doctor prescription cialis without a doctor prescription cialis for sale
https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra pillen kopen
TadalafilEasyBuy.com: Buy Tadalafil 5mg – cialis without a doctor prescription
Cialis 20mg price in USA: Tadalafil Easy Buy – Tadalafil price
http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic Viagra online
https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Cialis 20mg price
cialis without a doctor prescription: cialis without a doctor prescription – cialis without a doctor prescription
Generic 100mg Easy Viagra online price Generic100mgEasy
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# buy generic 100mg viagra online
Generic Cialis price: Buy Tadalafil 10mg – Tadalafil Easy Buy
https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com
Tadalafil Easy Buy: Generic Cialis without a doctor prescription – Tadalafil Easy Buy
https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Generic Tadalafil 20mg price
kamagra pillen kopen: Kamagra Kopen – kamagra jelly kopen
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# buy generic 100mg viagra online
cheapest cialis Tadalafil Easy Buy Cialis without a doctor prescription
http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Cheap Cialis
Tadalafil Easy Buy: Cheap Cialis – Buy Tadalafil 20mg
Kamagra: KamagraKopen.pro – KamagraKopen.pro
http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Tadalafil Easy Buy
https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# cialis without a doctor prescription
пин ап вход: https://pinupkz.life/
pinup 2025 – pinup 2025
Generic100mgEasy Generic 100mg Easy Generic 100mg Easy
пин ап вход – пин ап вход
пин ап: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап – пин ап казино зеркало
пин ап – pinup 2025
пинап казино – пин ап казино официальный сайт
пин ап зеркало – пин ап казино зеркало
TadalafilEasyBuy.com cialis without a doctor prescription Cialis 20mg price in USA
pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап казино – пин ап казино официальный сайт
пин ап казино зеркало – пин ап вход
пин ап казино официальный сайт – пин ап зеркало
пин ап казино: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап казино официальный сайт – пин ап
buy generic 100mg viagra online buy generic 100mg viagra online Generic100mgEasy
пин ап – пин ап вход
пинап казино – пин ап вход
pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап вход – пинап казино
TadalafilEasyBuy.com Tadalafil Easy Buy Tadalafil Easy Buy
пин ап казино зеркало – pinup 2025
pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/
Apotek hemleverans idag apotek online recept apotek online
https://apotheekmax.com/# Apotheek Max
Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen: Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept – kamagra
Kamagra Oral Jelly: Kamagra Oral Jelly – Kamagra online bestellen
https://apotheekmax.shop/# Apotheek Max
https://apotekonlinerecept.shop/# Apoteket online
Apotek hemleverans recept: Apoteket online – apotek pa nett
Apoteket online: Apotek hemleverans idag – apotek pa nett
Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept Kamagra Original kamagra
https://apotekonlinerecept.shop/# apotek pa nett