Charity trading subsidiaries as charities – the New Lanark decision
On 29 January 2021, the Inner House of the Court of Session in Scotland refused appeals made by the Scottish Charity Regulator OSCR against decisions of the Upper Tribunal in respect of two wholly owned subsidiary trading companies of the charity, the New Lanark Trust (NLT). Both trading companies had applied to OSCR to register as charities and OSCR had refused. The Upper Tribunal had quashed those decisions and directed OSCR to register the trading subsidiary companies on the Scottish charities register.
Although the decision is one of charity status, under Scottish charity law, there may be wider implications as, for example, the withdrawal of charity rates relief by South Lanarkshire Council from non-charitable subsidiaries was said to be a factor in the decision to apply to register.
The trading companies
NLT is the charity responsible for managing the UNESCO World Heritage Site at New Lanark. It was accepted in the case that it is crucial feature of the New Lanark site that it is not merely preserved, but maintained as a living village so that visitors may, so far as is practicable, experience the original concept which has led to its World Heritage designation.
To help it do this, NLT has two wholly-owned subsidiary trading companies, New Lanark Trading Limited (NL Trading) and New Lanark Hotels Limits (NL Hotels). NL Trading operates the visitor attraction and related trading activities, including a café, shop and the production and sale of ice cream. NL Hotels operates a hotel, hostels and self-catering lodges within the village, including a conference centre, wedding venue, bar, restaurant, leisure club, pool and beauty treatment facilities.
Both companies were formed with the principal purpose of producing income to donate by gift aid to NLT. They occupied as tenants buildings owned by NLT and were operated on a commercial basis. The purposes of both companies were only charitable, falling within the advancement of education and the advancement of the arts, heritage, culture or science. The issue before the court was whether they “provided public benefit” within the second limb of the charity test in s7(1) of the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005.
Were the trading companies charitable?
OSCR considered that NL Trading did not provide public benefit on the basis that a significant part of its activities, such as the shop, café and ice cream manufacturing, were neither in furtherance of its charitable purposes nor incidental to them, hence there was no public benefit arising from its activities as a whole. Similarly, in respect of NL Hotels, OSCR considered that operating the hotel, hostel and self-catering lodges were not in furtherance of its charitable purposes or a by-product of doing so. In each case, OSCR considered these activities to be non-charitable activities undertaken with the aim of generating profits to be applied for charitable purposes (i.e. fundraising) rather than activities which directly advanced a charitable purpose.
The First-tier Tribunal upheld OSCR’s decisions. Before the Upper Tribunal, it was accepted that the trading companies could not pass the charity test merely on the basis that each donated its surplus to NLT for charitable purposes. Similarly, the charitable activities of NLT could not be attributed to its trading companies. The issue was whether when carrying out their own commercial activities, they were each providing public benefit.
The Upper Tribunal found that OSCR’s approach had missed the point – in the overall setting of New Lanark the commercial activity in itself amounted to a public benefit. The question to ask was: did the commercial activities carried on contribute to the furtherance of the entity’s charitable purposes of advancement of education and heritage? On the evidence, the answer was yes. In the case of New Lanark, which was offered to the public as an inhabited, economically active settlement with facilities for visitors, the nature and size of the site necessitated provision of facilities for visitors. Providing those facilities and accommodation contributed to the objectives of maintaining the village as a living entity and to satisfying the needs and expectations of visitors.
While it was acknowledged that some elements of the services provided, such as a spa and beauty rooms, would seem to have little to do with advancement of education or heritage if considered on their own, the activities as a whole advanced the charitable purposes. The key point at the heart of both decisions was the presentation of the village as a functioning entity. The Inner House concluded that another tribunal might have reached a different decision, but the Upper Tribunal was entitled to make the findings which it did.
Primary purpose trading is not “fundraising”
It is also worth noting that, before the Inner House, OSCR objected that the Upper Tribunal had erred in not carrying out what OSCR considered to be a necessary balancing exercise, to identify which was the dominant purpose where an applicant for registration had dual purposes (of raising funds and contributing to its charitable purposes). However, the Inner House considered that such a balancing exercise was only needed where some activities had advanced the charitable purposes and some had not – in this case, the Upper Tribunal had found that all the activities furthered the charitable purposes. Where the trading activity is all “primary purpose trading”, the fact that it also raised money would not of itself deprive it of public benefit or mean that it had to fail the charity test. The court noted that “while simply raising funds for a charitable purpose does not meet the test, it would be odd if the mere fact that primary purpose trading activity generated funds destined for the same public benefit deprived it of charitable status”.
Guidance vs statute
OSCR also argued that the Upper Tribunal had mis-characterised its guidance and “should have interpreted the charity test consistently with that guidance”. The Inner House found that the Upper Tribunal was concerned instead to “make it clear that any guidance issued by OSCR could not be determinative of the legal interpretation of the statute”. The court added that this was a “proposition which seems to have been at the very least floated before the tribunals, although quite properly disavowed in this appeal”. The Upper Tribunal had not rejected the guidance or found it to be wrong, the decision was in fact in accordance with the guidance.
Comment
Both companies have now been entered on the Scottish charities register and, as identified in some of the accompanying press coverage, will be making applications for relief from non-domestic rates on the sites they occupy.
Other charities may look to this example and consider whether a similar model would work for them (whether under the Scottish test of providing public benefit or the English and Northern Ireland tests of the purpose itself being for the public benefit). Inevitably, any such example would turn on its facts. It was noted, for example, in this case that New Lanark was “considered almost to be unique”. It was crucial to the court’s finding that the trading companies’ activities enhanced the presentation of New Lanark as a “living village, contributing to the visitor experience which has given the site its reputation”. It is useful, however, that the court has provided clear guidance that charities can (and do) carry out “commercial” activities in furtherance of their purposes and that doing so need not detract from the charity’s public benefit.
Comments
alo789 chinh th?c: alo 789 – alo789
canada discount pharmacy: online canadian pharmacy no prescription – reputable canadian pharmacy
https://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican pharmacy online order
reliable canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy meds reviews: canada pharmacy no prescription – buy drugs from canada
https://indiamedfast.shop/# IndiaMedFast.com
canadian pharmacy no scripts
buying prescription drugs from india india online pharmacy store order medicines online india
mexican pharmacy online store: reliable mexican pharmacies – mexican pharmacy online
http://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican pharmacy online order
https://interpharmonline.shop/# best online canadian pharmacy
canadian drugs
buying prescription drugs from india: order medicines online india – cheapest online pharmacy india
medication canadian pharmacy certified canada pharmacy online pharmacies in canada that ship to the us
MexicanPharmInter: Mexican Pharm Inter – MexicanPharmInter
https://mexicanpharminter.shop/# Mexican Pharm Inter
http://interpharmonline.com/# best canadian pharmacy to buy from
trustworthy canadian pharmacy
buying drugs from canada: highest rated canadian online pharmacy – legitimate canadian mail order pharmacy
IndiaMedFast: buying prescription drugs from india – lowest prescription prices online india
http://indiamedfast.com/# IndiaMedFast
http://indiamedfast.com/# IndiaMedFast
best online canadian pharmacy
best online canadian pharmacy InterPharmOnline medication canadian pharmacy
India Med Fast: India Med Fast – India Med Fast
https://interpharmonline.shop/# cross border pharmacy canada
https://indiamedfast.shop/# lowest prescription prices online india
canadian online pharmacy
canada drugs online review: most trusted canadian pharmacies online – canadian pharmacy meds
https://interpharmonline.com/# canadian family pharmacy
https://mexicanpharminter.shop/# mexican pharmacy online store
canadian pharmacy near me
canadian pharmacy price checker: Online pharmacy USA – real canadian pharmacy
mexican pharmacy online store mexican pharmacy online order Mexican Pharm Inter
canadian pharmacy: highest rated canadian online pharmacy – maple leaf pharmacy in canada
https://indiamedfast.shop/# IndiaMedFast.com
http://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican pharmacy online store
prescription drugs canada buy online
cheapest online pharmacy india: india pharmacy without prescription – online medicine shopping in india
https://generic100mgeasy.com/# buy generic 100mg viagra online
Tadalafil Easy Buy: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – cialis without a doctor prescription
http://generic100mgeasy.com/# sildenafil 50 mg price
п»їcialis generic TadalafilEasyBuy.com cialis without a doctor prescription
Buy Tadalafil 20mg: Tadalafil Easy Buy – Tadalafil Easy Buy
https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen Online
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# buy generic 100mg viagra online
buy generic 100mg viagra online: cheap viagra – Generic100mgEasy
sildenafil over the counter: Generic100mgEasy – Generic100mgEasy
Viagra generic over the counter Generic100mgEasy Buy generic 100mg Viagra online
https://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic 100mg Easy
https://generic100mgeasy.com/# Viagra without a doctor prescription Canada
Tadalafil Easy Buy: Cialis without a doctor prescription – Generic Tadalafil 20mg price
Generic 100mg Easy: Viagra without a doctor prescription Canada – Sildenafil Citrate Tablets 100mg
https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com
https://kamagrakopen.pro/# KamagraKopen.pro
Generic 100mg Easy buy generic 100mg viagra online Generic 100mg Easy
cheapest viagra: Viagra online price – Generic 100mg Easy
Generic100mgEasy: Buy Viagra online cheap – Cheapest Sildenafil online
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# buy generic 100mg viagra online
http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# cialis for sale
Kamagra: kamagra 100mg kopen – kamagra pillen kopen
kamagra jelly kopen: KamagraKopen.pro – Kamagra Kopen
https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com
http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# TadalafilEasyBuy.com
TadalafilEasyBuy.com Tadalafil Easy Buy Buy Tadalafil 10mg
Officiele Kamagra van Nederland: kamagra 100mg kopen – Kamagra Kopen Online
https://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic 100mg Easy
cialis without a doctor prescription: Tadalafil Easy Buy – TadalafilEasyBuy.com
http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic 100mg Easy
buy generic 100mg viagra online: Generic 100mg Easy – buy generic 100mg viagra online
order viagra buy Viagra online Generic 100mg Easy
Tadalafil Easy Buy: Tadalafil Easy Buy – cialis without a doctor prescription
http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic 100mg Easy
http://generic100mgeasy.com/# viagra canada
cialis without a doctor prescription: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – cialis without a doctor prescription
Generic100mgEasy: Generic100mgEasy – Generic100mgEasy
https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen
https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# Viagra Tablet price
kamagra pillen kopen: kamagra 100mg kopen – Officiele Kamagra van Nederland
Kamagra Kopen Online kamagra 100mg kopen kamagra jelly kopen
https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# Tadalafil Easy Buy
TadalafilEasyBuy.com: Buy Cialis online – cialis for sale
https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Officiele Kamagra van Nederland
Cheap Viagra 100mg: Generic100mgEasy – Cheapest Sildenafil online
http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Cialis 20mg price
https://kamagrakopen.pro/# KamagraKopen.pro
kamagra gel kopen: Kamagra Kopen Online – Officiele Kamagra van Nederland
Cheapest Sildenafil online Generic 100mg Easy Generic 100mg Easy
Cialis over the counter: cialis for sale – Cheap Cialis
пин ап – пин ап
pinup 2025 – пин ап вход
пин ап казино – пин ап казино
пин ап зеркало – пин ап казино
пин ап казино зеркало: https://pinupkz.life/
cialis without a doctor prescription Tadalafil Easy Buy cialis without a doctor prescription
pinup 2025 – пин ап
пин ап зеркало – пин ап казино зеркало
pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап казино официальный сайт – пин ап казино
пин ап казино зеркало – пин ап вход
пин ап вход: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап казино – пин ап вход
Generic Viagra online Generic100mgEasy Generic 100mg Easy
пин ап казино зеркало – пин ап зеркало
pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап – пин ап казино
пин ап казино – пинап казино
Officiele Kamagra van Nederland Kamagra Kamagra Kopen Online
пин ап казино официальный сайт – пин ап
пин ап казино официальный сайт: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап казино – пин ап
пин ап казино официальный сайт – пин ап вход
пин ап зеркало: https://pinupkz.life/
пин ап – пин ап казино официальный сайт
Cheap generic Viagra Generic 100mg Easy buy generic 100mg viagra online
Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept: Apotheek Max – Apotheek Max
apotek online: apotek online recept – Apotek hemleverans idag
https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# apotek online recept
https://apotheekmax.com/# ApotheekMax
Apotek hemleverans recept: Apoteket online – apotek online recept
Kamagra Gel: Kamagra Gel – Kamagra online bestellen
Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept online apotheek ApotheekMax
https://kamagrapotenzmittel.com/# kamagra
https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apoteket online
Kamagra Original: Kamagra online bestellen – Kamagra Oral Jelly
Kamagra Original: Kamagra online bestellen – kamagra
https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# apotek pa nett
Beste online drogist online apotheek de online drogist kortingscode
http://apotekonlinerecept.com/# apotek pa nett
Kamagra online bestellen: Kamagra Original – Kamagra Original
kamagra: Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen – Kamagra Oral Jelly
https://apotheekmax.shop/# Beste online drogist
http://apotekonlinerecept.com/# apotek online recept
Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept: Kamagra Gel – Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept
Apotek hemleverans idag: Apotek hemleverans recept – Apoteket online
Kamagra Oral Jelly Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen
https://apotekonlinerecept.shop/# Apotek hemleverans recept
Apoteket online: Apoteket online – Apoteket online
https://kamagrapotenzmittel.shop/# Kamagra Oral Jelly
Apotheek online bestellen: Apotheek Max – Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept
https://apotheekmax.com/# Apotheek online bestellen
Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept: Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept – ApotheekMax
Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept kamagra Kamagra kaufen
https://kamagrapotenzmittel.com/# Kamagra Gel
http://apotheekmax.com/# ApotheekMax
Kamagra online bestellen: Kamagra Original – Kamagra Original
https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# apotek online recept
http://apotheekmax.com/# Online apotheek Nederland met recept
kamagra: Kamagra online bestellen – Kamagra kaufen
Kamagra Gel Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen Kamagra Original
http://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apoteket online
Online apotheek Nederland met recept: Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept – Online apotheek Nederland met recept
http://kamagrapotenzmittel.com/# Kamagra Original
apotek online: Apotek hemleverans recept – apotek online
https://apotekonlinerecept.shop/# Apoteket online
Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept: kamagra – Kamagra online bestellen
https://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apotek hemleverans idag
Kamagra kaufen Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept Kamagra Oral Jelly
kamagra: Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen – Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen
http://apotheekmax.com/# de online drogist kortingscode
https://kamagrapotenzmittel.com/# Kamagra Oral Jelly
de online drogist kortingscode: online apotheek – Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept
Beste online drogist: Apotheek Max – Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept
http://apotheekmax.com/# Beste online drogist
https://kamagrapotenzmittel.shop/# Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen
Apotheek Max de online drogist kortingscode de online drogist kortingscode
Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen: Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen – Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept
world pharmacy india: www india pharm – www india pharm
https://agbmexicopharm.shop/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
medicine in mexico pharmacies: Agb Mexico Pharm – Agb Mexico Pharm
www india pharm: www india pharm – reputable indian online pharmacy
www india pharm: www india pharm – top 10 online pharmacy in india
mexican pharmaceuticals online purple pharmacy mexico price list mexico drug stores pharmacies
https://agbmexicopharm.shop/# Agb Mexico Pharm
canada pharmacy: go canada pharm – canadapharmacyonline
best canadian pharmacy: GoCanadaPharm – safe online pharmacies in canada
Agb Mexico Pharm: medication from mexico pharmacy – mexican mail order pharmacies
https://agbmexicopharm.com/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
buy medicines online in india: www india pharm – Online medicine order
Agb Mexico Pharm: reputable mexican pharmacies online – Agb Mexico Pharm
Agb Mexico Pharm: pharmacies in mexico that ship to usa – Agb Mexico Pharm
www india pharm www india pharm buy medicines online in india
https://wwwindiapharm.shop/# world pharmacy india
medication canadian pharmacy: pet meds without vet prescription canada – my canadian pharmacy rx
legitimate canadian pharmacy online: go canada pharm – canadian pharmacy no scripts
Agb Mexico Pharm: Agb Mexico Pharm – mexican border pharmacies shipping to usa
best canadian pharmacy online: go canada pharm – canadian pharmacies
https://agbmexicopharm.com/# Agb Mexico Pharm
Agb Mexico Pharm best online pharmacies in mexico Agb Mexico Pharm
top online pharmacy india: best online pharmacy india – top 10 pharmacies in india
canada drug pharmacy: canadian drug pharmacy – canadianpharmacymeds com
medicine in mexico pharmacies: Agb Mexico Pharm – Agb Mexico Pharm
http://agbmexicopharm.com/# п»їbest mexican online pharmacies
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: Agb Mexico Pharm – Agb Mexico Pharm
canada pharmacy online legit: canadian pharmacy review – canadian pharmacy com
Agb Mexico Pharm: reputable mexican pharmacies online – Agb Mexico Pharm
mexican rx online best online pharmacies in mexico purple pharmacy mexico price list
canadian pharmacy online reviews: canadian king pharmacy – canadian drugs
https://gocanadapharm.shop/# canadapharmacyonline com
best canadian online pharmacy: GoCanadaPharm – canada pharmacy reviews