Charity VAT Recovery – The Road Not Taken

Given the relative lack of case decisions on the question of charity input tax recovery, the recent decision in Will Woodlands (TC06021) is welcome, particularly as it supported the case made by the charity.  This article gives my views as to what the case means and how it might assist charities.  However, these comments should be used with caution, since, in my view, the case was not one which HMRC had a realistic prospect of winning, and it may not therefore provide as much help in more borderline cases as one would wish.

The issue is the familiar one of how to attribute costs where the charity’s objective or motive is non-commercial, but the outcome of the activity is that taxable supplies are made.  Putting the question in deceptively simple terms: Is the cost partly ‘non-business’, simply because the motivation is not a business purpose, or is it wholly ‘business’, because that is what results from the activities?  To my mind, the answer to that simple question is simply that motive is irrelevant, and that it is the objective nature of the activity which determines the VAT recovery position.  And my views are supported by the decision in this case.  That said, matters are rarely as simple as this question presents them, or as simple (in my view, at least) as this case presents them.

This decision is also of special note because it is only the second decision in a UK court relating to the CJEU decision in Sveda as applying to charitiesThe first was last year’s decision in the case of Durham Cathedral (see my commentary on this case).  Whilst this is helpful, it is worth noting that the inception of this litigation pre-ceded the Sveda decision (which was not true of Durham), and clearly would have been decided in the same way had Sveda never existed.  Whilst this does not nullify the usefulness of the references to this important CJEU decision, it means that the case does not denote any great new development or novel opportunity.  Basically, the reliance on Sveda does no more than confirm what has been the position all along.

I should also mention that the facts concerning a woodland conservation charity are somewhat special, and do not obviously read across to charities in general.

Having dampened your expectations, I will now summarise what the case says.

The charity was set up with the object of conservation of woodlands largely for environmental reasons.  The ‘model’ involves running the woodlands as managed operations similar (in fact, identical) to that which is found in sustainable commercial forestry.  This means that the trees will be felled in due course and sold for timber, with occasional ‘thinning’ and sales of the off-cuts made as time goes by.  It is in the nature of such an activity that the substantial taxable income from sales arises decades later than the associated costs.  In the meantime, the conservation aims are met by reference to the management of each such woodland.  Various streams of income, such as grants, are continuously received (some of which sources of income are equally available to purely commercial operations).

HMRC agreed, some fifteen years ago, that the costs should be recovered on the basis that the relevant outcome in VAT terms is that they are cost components of a taxable supply.  More recently, HMRC changed its mind and stated that some account had to be made of the non-commercial charitable motivation of the appellant.  This could be achieved, they said, by assuming that some income was ‘non-business’, and thus gave rise to non-recovery.  Since the sales of timber were largely far in the future, HMRC postulated a dummy sales figure based on assumed sales values spread over the years it would take to generate the sales, and this was to be compared with the non-taxable actual streams of income.

To some extent, this newly suggested basis is secondary to the main point of the case, since, if the costs are deemed to have a direct and immediate link with taxable supplies, there is no need for any apportionment method, whether a tortuous one, or a rational one.  That said, the tribunal was withering in its criticism of HMRC’s suggested basis of apportionment, regarding it as completely unrealistic, and indicative of significant ignorance of the forestry industry.

But, of greater importance to us is the central theme of the litigation, which is whether ‘motive’ is important in determining VAT recovery.  Before the tribunal even considered Sveda, it turned to other decisions, particularly our own Court of Appeal decision in Longridge on the ThamesFrom this it deduced that the issue of ‘motive’ or over-arching ‘purpose’ is irrelevant.  The VAT treatment is determined by the objective character of the activity, and the purpose or result is irrelevant as such.  This principle had been used in Longridge to decide that there was an economic activity (and thus not a relevant charitable purpose), which is a different point to input tax recovery, but the tribunal in Will Woodlands was clear that this is a distinction without a difference.  The input tax analysis is essentially the same as that for outputs.

Only then did the tribunal turn to Sveda (having already decided the case in the charity’s favour).  But it is here that the theme continues in a useful vein.  HMRC’s argument was that Sveda concerned a purely commercial supplier which had received a grant to build a path in a wood (ironically) and which therefore had only the one, commercial, motive, since the path led directly to a shop from which it sold taxable goods.  This reliance on motive was not approved by the tribunal.  It thought that the charity’s operation was a commercial one, and that is all that counted.  Indeed, whereas the Sveda example involved costs for a means of access to the taxable products, the woodland costs, in our case, actually engendered the very product that was intended to be sold.  This was a closer link to the final taxable supplies than arises in a cost of giving access.  Whereas the section of the decision on Sveda does not seem explicitly to state that ‘motive does not matter’, when combined with the commentary on Longridge, that is the net result.

In summary, this case was an extremely aggressive one for HMRC to take, particularly given that it was seemingly based on scant preparation.  The case could have been decided from basic VAT principles almost without any reference to case precedent.  But the case precedent of Longridge and Sveda – both fairly recent decisions of very senior courts – put the matter beyond all realistic doubt, and seems to me to have confirmed that a charity’s objects or ‘motive’ are not relevant in determining the right to input tax recovery.

Comments

  1. David Arkinstall says:

    Graham, don’t know whether you agree but it seemed to me that some ancilliary work such as maintaining a pond within the woodland and work to footpaths within the woodland were seen as being closely linked to the forestry work and Vat therefore recoverable on associate costs?

  2. pamela Bytheway says:

    Hello, I read your article with interest because we are an Animal Sanctuary concerned about the affect on wild life habita next to our sanctuary site. Ancient woodland was included in an old hospital site purchased by developers which is now in the second phase of building on the opposite side of the woodland. The Sanctuary purchased the field next door to our site to protect habita and access accross to the woods. We have huge domestic annual animal welfare running costs and I am sure we could be zero rated iwith regard to non business supplies. The building of a new kennel block for our rescue dogs meant a £160,000 VAT Bill that almost emptied our reserves. However, the wild life issue could not be ignored and so we have managed to secure Enviodnmental funding to help us create a Biodiversity Project to install a pond and bat folly, and create a WIld Flower Meadow in the new field. Included is a Meadow Store, Barn and Land Tractor and wild life friendly fencing. I am certain that the kennel block should have been zero rated and I am growing in certainty that the environmental purchases may qualify for zero rating too if presenting a zero rating certificate to our suppliers. We are a Registered Charity, registered for VAT although very little of that is buisness related and so we have few commercial aspects to set against lnput Tax . Are we entitled to apply to our suppliers to claim zero rating on our not for profit related purchases such as the new meadow building to house the tractor and flower seed, or even the pond installation and building of the bat folly. We cannot seem to get the right advice. Your help would be so appreciated.

  3. JeromeCoalm says:

    alo789hk: alo789 – alo789in

  4. GeorgeAdect says:

    canada pharmacy 24h: canada pharmacy no prescription – pet meds without vet prescription canada

  5. MonteSmure says:

    online pharmacy india cheapest online pharmacy india order medicines online india

  6. ArthurSaulk says:

    http://interpharmonline.com/# best rated canadian pharmacy
    reliable canadian pharmacy reviews

  7. Jamesbub says:

    Mexican Pharm Inter: MexicanPharmInter – mexican pharmacy online

  8. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.com/# online medicine shopping in india

  9. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.shop/# mexican pharmacy online store
    best rated canadian pharmacy

  10. Jamesbub says:

    mexican pharmacy online store: MexicanPharmInter – mexican pharmacy online order

  11. MonteSmure says:

    lowest prescription prices online india cheapest online pharmacy india lowest prescription prices online india

  12. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.com/# IndiaMedFast

  13. ArthurSaulk says:

    http://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican pharmacy online
    onlinecanadianpharmacy 24

  14. GeorgeAdect says:

    canadadrugpharmacy com: highest rated canadian online pharmacy – canadian mail order pharmacy

  15. Jamesbub says:

    canadian pharmacy world: canadian drugstore online no prescription – reliable canadian pharmacy

  16. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.com/# IndiaMedFast.com

  17. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.com/# mexican pharmacy online order
    vipps approved canadian online pharmacy

  18. Jamesbub says:

    order medicines online india: cheapest online pharmacy india – IndiaMedFast.com

  19. MonteSmure says:

    canadian pharmacy price checker canada pharmacy no prescription best canadian online pharmacy

  20. GeorgeAdect says:

    canadian online pharmacy reviews: canadian drugstore online no prescription – best canadian online pharmacy reviews

  21. Willisgal says:

    https://interpharmonline.shop/# legitimate canadian pharmacies

  22. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://interpharmonline.shop/# ed meds online canada
    canadian pharmacy cheap

  23. Jamesbub says:

    IndiaMedFast.com: india pharmacy without prescription – IndiaMedFast

  24. Willisgal says:

    https://indiamedfast.shop/# online medicine shopping in india

  25. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://interpharmonline.shop/# real canadian pharmacy
    canada pharmacy reviews

  26. MonteSmure says:

    online canadian pharmacy Online pharmacy USA canadian pharmacy

  27. HowardNag says:

    canadian pharmacies: Pharmacies in Canada that ship to the US – canada discount pharmacy

  28. Jamesbub says:

    mexican drug stores online: mexican pharmacy online order – reliable mexican pharmacies

  29. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://interpharmonline.shop/# best canadian pharmacy to order from
    pharmacy canadian superstore

  30. HowardNag says:

    pharmacy rx world canada: Inter Pharm Online – best online canadian pharmacy

  31. Jamesbub says:

    buying prescription drugs from india: IndiaMedFast – online medicine shopping in india

  32. MonteSmure says:

    mexican pharmacy online mexican pharmacy online reliable mexican pharmacies

  33. Willisgal says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.com/# Mexican Pharm International

  34. ArthurSaulk says:

    https://mexicanpharminter.shop/# Mexican Pharm International
    canadian drug stores

  35. Terrynom says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen

  36. Williamaxowl says:

    kamagra pillen kopen: kamagra gel kopen – Kamagra Kopen Online

  37. Kennethsnoda says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Viagra without a doctor prescription Canada

  38. GregorypeF says:

    kamagra kopen nederland: Officiele Kamagra van Nederland – Officiele Kamagra van Nederland

  39. Dwaynethine says:

    kamagra 100mg kopen Kamagra kamagra jelly kopen

  40. Terrynom says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra 100mg kopen

  41. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen Online

  42. Williamaxowl says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com: Tadalafil Tablet – cialis without a doctor prescription

  43. GregorypeF says:

    cheapest viagra: buy generic 100mg viagra online – buy generic 100mg viagra online

  44. Terrynom says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Buy Cialis online

  45. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra jelly kopen

  46. GregorypeF says:

    kamagra 100mg kopen: kamagra kopen nederland – Kamagra Kopen Online

  47. Dwaynethine says:

    Generic 100mg Easy sildenafil online Generic100mgEasy

  48. Williamaxowl says:

    Tadalafil Easy Buy: TadalafilEasyBuy.com – TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  49. Terrynom says:

    http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Tadalafil Easy Buy

  50. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.shop/# cialis without a doctor prescription

  51. GregorypeF says:

    Officiele Kamagra van Nederland: Officiele Kamagra van Nederland – kamagra 100mg kopen

  52. Williamaxowl says:

    kamagra jelly kopen: Kamagra – kamagra jelly kopen

  53. Terrynom says:

    http://tadalafileasybuy.com/# п»їcialis generic

  54. Dwaynethine says:

    Generic100mgEasy Generic 100mg Easy Cheap Sildenafil 100mg

  55. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://generic100mgeasy.shop/# Generic 100mg Easy

  56. Williamaxowl says:

    Generic 100mg Easy: Buy generic 100mg Viagra online – sildenafil online

  57. GregorypeF says:

    Generic 100mg Easy: Generic100mgEasy – order viagra

  58. Terrynom says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra 100mg kopen

  59. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra gel kopen

  60. Williamaxowl says:

    Tadalafil Easy Buy: Tadalafil Easy Buy – Cialis without a doctor prescription

  61. GregorypeF says:

    cialis for sale: п»їcialis generic – Tadalafil price

  62. Dwaynethine says:

    TadalafilEasyBuy.com cialis without a doctor prescription cialis without a doctor prescription

  63. Terrynom says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Generic Tadalafil 20mg price

  64. Williamaxowl says:

    Tadalafil price: cialis without a doctor prescription – cialis without a doctor prescription

  65. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# cialis without a doctor prescription

  66. GregorypeF says:

    buy Viagra online: buy generic 100mg viagra online – buy generic 100mg viagra online

  67. Williamaxowl says:

    Generic100mgEasy: buy generic 100mg viagra online – Generic100mgEasy

  68. Terrynom says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# Tadalafil Easy Buy

  69. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# kamagra gel kopen

  70. Dwaynethine says:

    Viagra tablet online Generic100mgEasy Generic100mgEasy

  71. Williamaxowl says:

    Tadalafil price: Tadalafil Easy Buy – TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  72. GregorypeF says:

    Buy generic 100mg Viagra online: buy generic 100mg viagra online – Generic100mgEasy

  73. Terrynom says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# buy generic 100mg viagra online

  74. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://kamagrakopen.pro/# Kamagra Kopen Online

  75. GregorypeF says:

    sildenafil over the counter: buy generic 100mg viagra online – Buy generic 100mg Viagra online

  76. Williamaxowl says:

    cialis without a doctor prescription: cialis without a doctor prescription – TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  77. Kennethsnoda says:

    https://tadalafileasybuy.com/# cialis without a doctor prescription

  78. Dwaynethine says:

    buy generic 100mg viagra online Viagra tablet online Generic 100mg Easy

  79. Terrynom says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# generic sildenafil

  80. GregorypeF says:

    Generic 100mg Easy: Viagra tablet online – Generic 100mg Easy

  81. Kennethsnoda says:

    http://generic100mgeasy.com/# Generic 100mg Easy

  82. WilliamSaink says:

    пинап казино – пин ап казино зеркало

  83. Dwaynethine says:

    Officiele Kamagra van Nederland kamagra kopen nederland Kamagra Kopen Online

  84. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап вход – пин ап вход

  85. JamesVal says:

    пин ап – пинап казино

  86. Jessenuh says:

    пинап казино: https://pinupkz.life/

  87. WilliamSaink says:

    pinup 2025 – пин ап казино зеркало

  88. JamesVal says:

    пин ап казино – пин ап казино

  89. Jessenuh says:

    pinup 2025: https://pinupkz.life/

  90. JamesVal says:

    pinup 2025 – пин ап казино зеркало

  91. Dwaynethine says:

    Generic Tadalafil 20mg price cialis without a doctor prescription TadalafilEasyBuy.com

  92. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап казино – пин ап казино

  93. JamesVal says:

    пин ап казино зеркало – пин ап вход

  94. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап вход – пин ап зеркало

  95. JamesVal says:

    пин ап вход – пин ап

  96. Www.Keeperexchange.Org says:

    70918248

    References:

    1 Cycle Of Steroids (http://Www.Keeperexchange.Org)

  97. Dwaynethine says:

    KamagraKopen.pro kamagra gel kopen KamagraKopen.pro

  98. Jessenuh says:

    пин ап казино зеркало: https://pinupkz.life/

  99. WilliamSaink says:

    пин ап – пин ап казино официальный сайт

  100. JamesVal says:

    pinup 2025 – пинап казино

  101. https://git.medianation.ru says:

    70918248

    References:

    Rock On steroids [https://git.medianation.ru]

  102. Michaelsip says:

    Apotek hemleverans idag: Apoteket online – Apotek hemleverans recept

  103. Derekscory says:

    de online drogist kortingscode: Beste online drogist – Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept

  104. Louisbeece says:

    https://kamagrapotenzmittel.shop/# Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept

  105. Michaelsip says:

    online apotheek: Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept – Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept

  106. Derekscory says:

    Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept: Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen – Kamagra kaufen ohne Rezept

  107. Louisbeece says:

    http://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apoteket online

  108. Malcolmtut says:

    Beste online drogist Apotheek online bestellen Apotheek Max

  109. Derekscory says:

    Apotek hemleverans recept: apotek pa nett – Apotek hemleverans idag

  110. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotheekmax.com/# Beste online drogist

  111. HomerCob says:

    https://kamagrapotenzmittel.shop/# Kamagra online bestellen

  112. git.ccchao.myds.me says:

    70918248

    References:

    closest thing to steroids but legal (git.ccchao.myds.me)

  113. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotheekmax.com/# Beste online drogist

  114. Derekscory says:

    Apoteket online: Apoteket online – apotek pa nett

  115. Michaelsip says:

    apotek pa nett: apotek online recept – apotek online

  116. www.etoilegym.fr says:

    70918248

    References:

    first steroid cycle (http://www.etoilegym.fr)

  117. Malcolmtut says:

    Apotek hemleverans idag apotek pa nett Apoteket online

  118. HomerCob says:

    http://apotheekmax.com/# Apotheek online bestellen

  119. Louisbeece says:

    http://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apotek hemleverans idag

  120. Derekscory says:

    Apoteket online: apotek online – Apotek hemleverans recept

  121. Michaelsip says:

    Kamagra online bestellen: Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen – Kamagra kaufen

  122. HomerCob says:

    http://kamagrapotenzmittel.com/# Kamagra Oral Jelly kaufen

  123. Malcolmtut says:

    Apotek hemleverans idag apotek online Apotek hemleverans recept

  124. Derekscory says:

    Apotek hemleverans idag: apotek online recept – Apotek hemleverans idag

  125. Michaelsip says:

    de online drogist kortingscode: de online drogist kortingscode – Beste online drogist

  126. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotheekmax.shop/# Beste online drogist

  127. Derekscory says:

    Apotheek online bestellen: ApotheekMax – Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept

  128. Louisbeece says:

    http://apotekonlinerecept.com/# Apoteket online

  129. Michaelsip says:

    ApotheekMax: Online apotheek Nederland zonder recept – online apotheek

  130. Malcolmtut says:

    online apotheek de online drogist kortingscode Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept

  131. Louisbeece says:

    https://apotheekmax.shop/# Betrouwbare online apotheek zonder recept

Join the discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *